We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
141-160 of 902

Physician’s Formula’s Custom Eye Enhancing Kohl Kajal Eyeliner Trio for Brown Eyes

5 reviews

I was completely disappointed in this product. I did love the pigmentation and how they went on. However, they broke after a couple of uses. One broke from being in my purse. It was a waste of money.
L'Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner

6 reviews

The chunkiness of this eyeliner makes it almost impossible to use as a daily product unless you’re going for that goth look! Also, the pigment isn’t great, which means to get it to black, instead of just grey, you have to go over your line a few times!
L'Oreal Carbon Black Extra Intense Liquid Pencil Eyeliner

19 reviews

I really love the L'oreal carbon black liquid eyeliner. It is smooth and easy to apply and lasts all day / night. It doesn't smudge or go into your crease either. I really appreciate a product I can trust and this is one of them!
NYX Single Eyeshadow

5 reviews

A nice eyeshadow..very creamy... lots of colors... I love using eye shadow and I would buy this product again.. I love using eyeshadow to give my eyes a pop of color
Revlon Sharpener

1 review

i could never imagine myself spending so much money on something i feel should be so cheap, especially when you can almost always pick them up for around 99 cents. i picked this one up because i was very upset about my cheap sharpeners ruining some of my favorite pencils. and to...
physician formula Eye Booster™2-in-1 Lash Boosting Eyeliner + Serum

53 reviews

This is another holy grail item of mine! I’ve been using this eyeliner for years and I haven’t found anything that compares. The brush tip makes application extremely easy and allows for a clean flick when I’m winging my liner. The colour stays all day and I don’t have...
Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner

7 reviews

This is my all time favourite eye liner, from the brush shape to the formula's staying powder. Too bad they don't sell this in Canada, I stock up every time I visit Asia.
BH Cosmetics Liquid Eyeliner

3 reviews

I've purchased about 15 of these throughout my life. I love them! They apply dark, the tip is really easy to use for precision lining. They last a long time, and are very inexpensive! I live in Canada, and even with the U.S. conversion + shipping, it's still worth ordering. I...
BH Cosmetics Waterproof Eyeliners

1 review

When I use eyeliner, I like to be able to smudge or blend it for a more natural look - I'm not a fan of a super straight and harsh line. Although BH Waterproof Eyeliners ($2.77) are said to be smudgeable and blendable, I found they were quite hard to work with. Not matter what...
Hard Candy Walk the Line Eye Liner

14 reviews

Took this to my makeup class and test some of the best name brand makeup removers and this stuff was by far the best! Nothing removed it making it great for weddings as it's the ultimate waterproof ! When I had a motorbike this with took the winds making my eyes water and...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Essentials Liquid Eye Liner

50 reviews

Didn't care for this product. I found that the brush picks you quite a bit of product making it near impossible to have a nice fine line without some blowouts. I also found the brush too long and flimsy and difficult to use. Great price but terrible design.
essence I Love Rock Gloss Eye Pencil

5 reviews

This goes on really smoothly for bold lines, but it lasts for less than a few hours. If you're not into getting a greasy grunge look not even halfway into the day, then skip this one.
Wet n' Wild Gel Eyeliner: Eggplant

1 review

This eyeliner is one of many new drugstore versions of popular department store brand cream and gel eyeliners. Revlon, Loreal, and Maybelline have all come out with their own line of gel eyeliners and the quality of each of these eyeliners differ from brand to brand. I was...
Wet n Wild Megalast Eyeliner

4 reviews

This is my favourite eyeliner to use! I’m not sure if it’s called “megalast” eyeliner because it’s supposed to last on your eyes all day or because the pencil itself lasts for ages - either way, it’s an appropriate name. Let’s start off with the obvious main...
Revlon Luxurious Color Smoky Crayon in Bronze Smoke

1 review

I keep buying brown eye pencils in the hunt for my perfect brown shade but some are either too light and fail to show up on my waterline or are too dark, that they almost appear black on my eyes. This one shows up well on my lower eyelids, a feat very few eye pencils have...
Bonne Bell Eyeliner

6 reviews

This is my FAVE eyeliner and pretty much the only one I can use. I've pretty much used this eye liner since I was a teenager and the only one that does not irritate my eyes. I have noticed with different brands that my eyes feel watery and itchy and get blurry within 5 minutes...
essence Eye Liner Pen

27 reviews

This is a fantastic eyeliner. It goes on very smoothly and is easy to create a nice straight line. It is very inexpensive and never tested on animals which is a big win! I always have this in my drawer.
i love my eyes eyeliner pencil

1 review

well, i recently bought this eyeliner pencil called "love my eyes". i should have known better because i bought it from a dollar general, but only because it was cheap. it worked at first...that is, until the weather started getting warmer and i found my eyeliner was smudging. i...
COVERGIRL LineBlast 24HR Eyeliner

6 reviews

Long wearing. Great price. Looks amazing would definitely recommend to my other friends. Normally don't cheap out and buy drug store stuff but I did and I love it.
Model 21 False Eyelashes No. 2T

2 reviews

Uses: Up To 15 Wears Material: 3D Mink Effect: Full Body, Wispy Volume: Natural Shape: Round Length: 15mm Uses: Up To 15 Wears Material: 3D Mink Effect: Full Body, Wispy Volume: Natural Shape: Round Length: 15mmi