Wouldn’t buy again

I am not at all impressed with this make up remover. I have to practically scrub to get my eye make up to come off using this. I’ll definitely stick to my usual eye make up remover.

This remover takes quite a bit of effort to remove my non-waterproof eyeshadow. It also stings the eyes if I get it in. I have used makeup removers that are the same price and 3 times more effective.

Unfortunately this product is not gentle whatsoever. My eyes and skin burned from using this. I had to throw out a whole bottle due to not being able to use it.

This make up remover works so well even on waterproof makeup. The only drawback is it leaves an oily residue after use so I have to wash my face with cleanser right after (which I would do anyway but some people don't like the extra step). I find that I only need two cotton pads to remove a whole face of makeup with this.

Almay Oil Free Eye Makeup Remover Liquid is a wonderful product. I like the fact that it is oil free. I am a contact wearer and this is the best remover I have found. Works amazing. Easy on skin.

I was thinking of buying Mary Kay's but at Walmart I breezed through and found this for just under 7$. The dispenser is a little weird- it should come out better but it is amazing as taking off the eye shadow, mascara and eye liner all at once without feeling dry or weird. Very gentle and well worth the time it took to locate it!

Lately I've been searching for a new eye-makeup remover, and have tried very many as a result. None of them have blown me away, and they all seemed to do the same thing. All the other products I tried either left a residue, or did a bad job at removing all my makeup. I feel like I finally found a middle ground with this product. It is definitely the best I've tried so far! I used to use this one a long time ago, but stopped using it I think because it went up in price compared to other brands. Right now its price seems to be fairly level with most other brands, so I don't see price as an issue anymore. I'm also willing to pay a bit more for a product that seems to work. I'm so glad I decided to use it again. It removes all of my eye-makeup (even mascara), is gentle on my eyes and doesn't leave an oily residue. I only wear washable makeup, so unfortunately I can't comment on how well it works for waterproof products. As far as non-waterproof makeup goes though, this remover works really well for me.

When I used Almay eye makeup remover I found that the "oil free" aspect was great because I wasn't getting blurred vision, etc. I did find, however, that it took a little longer to get my mascara off. I used a make off pad instead of a cotton ball and found that a little easier on my lashes.

I have been using Almay makeup remover for a few years now because of the "oil free" factor. I really dislike the oily makeup remover feeling on my eyes! Granted, this product may take a little extra rubbing compared to an oilier product, I still would rather finish not feeling oily. Unless I can find a non-oily feeling alternative, I'll definitely be sticking to Almay!

This did not remove my eye make-up very well. I ended up using more than I needed and rubbing my eyes too roughly. Would not buy this again!