This high end eyeliner did not deliver!

Definitely do not recommend. It does not glide on smoothly and it’s not worth the price. It’s a good concept but definitely a miss. Drugstore eyeliners are way better than this product and it’s less the price.

Unintentional Smokey eye with Benefit Pushup Eyeliner

If you're looking for precision, this not the liner for you...if your toddlers need new crayons--hey you can repurpose your $$ purchase!

I tried this and hated it instantly, it feels like goop/crayon and the brush is completely useless as it doesn't allow for a straight line to go anywhere...

I returned the product 1 day after trying it.

Omg save yourself the time, energy, and total frustration you'll experience when buying this eyeliner... just stay away. It has THEEE WORST applicator pen push up thing... you crank it and would expect a somewhat smooth gel would come out.... NAHHHH not happening.... its hard to apply and crumbles if you try to get a solid dark black line... which is kinda the point of gel and liquid liners

So I have 3 of these and none of them work. I've watched YouTube tutorials to see how to properly use them, and nothing. It's like there is nothing in the tubes. I squeeze, and nothing comes out. I squeeze up and down the tube many many many times and an entire chunk of eyeliner comes out of the tip. It's not gel, it's like thick putty like texture. Nothing appears on my eyes and it just crumbles. Horrible horrible product, especially for the ridiculous price.

I hated this liner. Looked so good on packaging but does not go on smooth. So disappointed because I adore benefit products usually. Don't waste your money.

Honestly you need an instruction manual to figure out how to properly use this product. It's so complicated just for an eyeliner, and once you get it to work, it's just a black eyeliner, there's nothing special about it.

I don't like negative reviews. However, I absolutely hated this product! It did not work well at all for me. It was messy, and not effective at all. It's high in price and does not have good quality at all. It is very hard to create an even cat eye or liner look. It smudged so easy and I have a very steady hand. Just not my cup of tea!