I stink at applying eyeliner. The applicator can be a bit tricky. But the formula lasts a long time like 48 hours! It is really easy to do a cat eye with this liner

Although without a primer this liner can smudge for those of us with oily lids the application of They're real liner is fantastic. I never have a morning anymore where I'm struggling when one eye liner is thicker than the other.

I love this eyeliner! It's waterproof which is great! The tip really helps with application and it's a gel liner which allows for smooth application.

This eye liner is great once you figure out how to use it!

I'm used to pencil liners, but this liner provides more pop and a thicker line to really make my eyes dazzle.

It's kind of like painting your eyebrow line on.

Works effectively and long lasting. However it is harder to put on than other liners

Ok, so I know that some people either love or hate this eyeliner; I love it. Granted, it is very tricky to use the very first times only, but really, follow the instructions and/or watch a few tutorials, and then Voila! Just remember to wipe off one click's worth of product before each use so that it doesn't go on to thick, and, replace the cover immediately so that it doesn't dry out. It just takes a little practice is all.

The gel liner is really budge proof! It stay's put! The color is a rich glossy black shade and the applicator tip is rubberized allowing you to line and smudge without any irritation or tugging on the lids or the water line. You can create fine lines or go bold with the pen tip. The pen twists up for product and sometimes extra comes out. I really like the product except for the fact it's difficult for me to remove it off my sensitive lids. Maybe I'll try it again with other removers but so far I used a few products as well as oil based removers. The oil removers helped a lot but I find I don't want to have to go through all the tugging every time I'm using this. I guess it would be okay for creating certain looks or every now and then but I can't see myself using this everyday.

I know this isn't a 'new product'.... and honestly, I don't really go for the brand spanking new products. I'm sure many people already have this but I love it so I wanted to review it...
It took some getting used to at first; I had to remind myself that it is a gel liner and not liquid. I love gel liners and the fact that this is in pen form... perfect!

After taking the protective piece off of the top and turning the bottom I started getting nervous because the recommended one or two clicks wasn't cutting it; it took around 20 or so. I thought I had a dud but alas, product found it's way to the opening. Now to play...

I have hooded lids, one a bit more than the other so I always had difficulties with liquid liners but the They're Real Push Up Liner definitely makes it easier.

Even though I love the pin-up winged liner, I'm not the best at it but my gosh, I did it.

The pen top is amazing. It's very smooth across the lid and gets right into the lash line. (it makes tight lining so easy!). It works like an angle brush but better because there are no bristles that can get pushed out of place and mess up your work, only a flexible silicone chisel tip.

Other black gel liners I've used had a green, grey or sometimes navy tint to them but this liner is actually black... matte black, which we all know is a staple in everyone's makeup kit.

It stayed on all day even when I was at work for hours with my head in steam.. It was crazy to come home and find my liner still in place. It lasted even through a shower! I broke the cardinal rule of beauty and didn't take my makeup off before bed and about 90% of it was still on the next morning. Taking it off was a bit of a task but that's not necessarily a bad thing. The They're Real Makeup remover (which I have not yet tried), will be a fantastic companion I'm sure.

I love this liner! I thought it was going to be difficult to use since the tip is like rubber but it's actually not. I love the formula and how black it is. I love how it makes making wings a piece of cake. The only thing I really didn't like is how much product comes out when you twist it.

I love this liner! I thought it was going to be difficult to use since the tip is like rubber but it's actually not. I love the formula and how black it is. I love how it makes making wings a piece of cake. The only thing I really didn't like is how much product comes out when you twist it.