So I am a eyeliner fein but seriously I hate this product I have never had a eyeliner smudge so badly! It is also so deceiving it looks so amazing when you put it on and is great to work with but five minutes later or a little heat and it looks like someone slugged both your eyes!

I love this eyeliner it goes on nicely without having to apply too much pressure, and it does look like liquid. I do find that it gets dull fairly quickly though.

Really great if you want a smokey eye! The smudging tool really works. Stayed put all day. I bought the brown so it's great for day time use. Would buy it again for sure!

love all the colors cant wait to go buy it :D !!!!!

I was very impressed with this eyeliner! I got this in brown blaze. It goes on so softly, really just like a liquid. It looks great dotted along the lashline or as a sold line (comes with a sponge smudger on the other end). I found this gave me great definition and made my eyes pop and my lashline look thicker. Plus, it lasted all day. I'll definitely use this again!

Hate this eyeliner. It's the only eyeliner to ever give me allergies and my body just doesn't agree with me. One of the shades I was able to wear for a few days before it gave me issues but the blue one made my eyes itchy and sore. Before I had the reaction though, it smudged all over the place and disappeared in a matter of a couple of hours. Not impressed! Off to search for a better eyeliner...

BEST. EYELINER. EVER.

I have pretty oily lids and any pencil liner I've used smudges on me literally in a blink of an eye. This one, however, smudges the least for me, and I was actually amazed at how little it smudged after a few hours of wear. This eyeliner is waterproof, and allows for intentional smudging and softening using the sponge tip that is on the pencil.

I saw a few reviews on the CG site of complaints that they were not warned about the fact that this liner needs to be sharpened and that it didn't come with one. Come on. It's not that difficult to get a sharpener (and any professional liners you'll find need sharpening as well). Anyway, it's well worth the 'trouble'.

All in all, it's definitely worth every penny, especially if you have oily lids or sensitive/watery eyes. Also perfect for the smoky look. I received my first one from ChickAdvisor and didn't wait long to get more in different colors!

This eyeliner goes on like a liquid, but it's not! It is soft and rolls on just like a liquid and the smudger on the end blends the liner gently. Many eyeliners, over wear time, end up giving me raccoon eyes, but this one does not. It does absorb over time, but for the most part it stays where it's supposed to. I didn't have trouble sharpening it. I found it at a great price too, which always make the deal sweeter.

LOVE this eyeliner! Better than average price. Colour selection isn't that large, but the one I have is purple (it doesn't have a name on it), and is great! It is the best eyeliner I've ever used, as it glides on really nice and the colour really stands out! It also has a smudger on one end. The only complaint I have is that it doesn't sharpen well with my regular sharpener as it is soft. So I need to find a different sharpener for it.