Most of these eyeshadows are pretty pigmented, which works well for a smokey look. But a couple of the shades are less pigmented, and these tend to be the matte ones. I do think a primer is necessary for this, as a couple shades are also on the powdery side. The included eyeliner is ok, and it works in a pinch, but doesn't last a super long time. I also don't really pay attention to the diagrams, but they are helpful for beginners. I don't really care for the mirror, I'd rather have more eyeshadows or primer in that space.

almost everything from ELF is worth it especially their eyeshadows. I have this book and it is very inexpensive and gives instructions on how to apply!

Great product! You get a great selection of colours that you can do a ton of different looks with! the shadows themselves are lovely and soft, making them super easy to blend and they are all unbelievably pigmented! you really get your moneys worth! a great set to bring with you when your traveling because it really gives you all the options you need for both day and night!

I am in love with this palette. Its got from light warm shadows to dark grays and browns, which allows you to create looks such as neutrals or the famous smoky eye. They are long lasting, very pigmented, easy to blend, interesting packaging.
I was very surprised with the quality of these eye shadows the moment i put them on , for such a low price. Im pretty sure the low price is one of the marketing strategies but hey! there is nothing wrong with that.
I would absolutely recommend this product . I ve been using it everyday since the time I bought them.