Great mascara... in the beginning

I really liked this mascara initially. However, after about a month, it started clumping and it didn’t layer as well for me. I was quite disappointed and will have to get rid of it after only using a for a month.

L’Oréal lash paradise

At first when I purchased this mascara I was in love!!!! This mascara was everything it was a dupe for too faced better than sex mascara. But after a while of not using it everyday the formula became really thick and clogged the wand and became dry and hard to use only after 1-2 months after purchasing!

Not my favourite

Unfortunately, when it comes to waterproof mascaras, this one is not my favourite. I use the non-waterproof version of this all the time and find it flawless and would highly recommend it. I find the waterproof version does not go on my lashes very nice and it clumps and sticks TOO well. I find it extremely hard to get off at the end of the day.

No smudging!!

I have very low eyelids so mascara tends to always rub off on them...yes even waterproof mascara. Not this one!! I can wear it all day long and it doesn't smudge. The actual mascara does go on a little thick so I just run it along the edge of the tube before applying.

Good drugstore option for waterproof mascara

After all of the hype this product garnered, I was expecting to be blown away. For the most part, I'm satisfied - it adds volume and length and stays in place all day long on the top lashes. That being said, I find the applicator got clumpy a bit too quickly (I'm not even halfway through the tube), and as a result, I can't really use it on my lower lashes without making a mess.

Almost perfect!

I tend to use waterproof formulas for the added curl (I have one eye with lashes that refuse to stay curled) and as much as I do like the TF Better than Sex, it's a bit pricey for a mascara. This formula is said to be comparable, and after trying it for a few weeks, I agree. That said, I might actually prefer L'Oreal better, as it isn't as dry a formula and I find I don't get the same crumbling and clumping the TF formula gets if you use too much. I love that this formula is super black and that it adds a lot of length and volume. I often feel the need to layer a non-waterproof mascara over other formulas for added length, but with this I really don't need to. It's pretty great!

L’Oréal Mascara

This is a good product but it’s not for me. I have read rave reviews and bought it. I didn’t like it because it dries and crumbles which falls right under my eyes. I end up with raccoon eyes. I think the price is right but it’s not right for me. It does give your eyelashes volume.

Great waterproof mascara

Great waterproof mascara. A little clumpy if you don't wipe the brush off before using, but definitely not a deal breaker. Not incredibly difficult to remove with a good waterproof make-up remover so that's a plus!

Heavy & clumpy

I bought this mascara not too long ago because I heard really good things about it, but its super heavy and the packaging is bad quality, most of the lettering has rubbed off my now. But if you're into volume when it comes to mascara, this is the one for you.

Really is waterproof!

Lash Paradise, the waterproof version, stayed on my lashes through two experiences on the same evening while I was on vacation. There was a storm and we had to run from one venue to another. It was raining hard on us and my mascara didn't smear or run. Later that evening, I cried, unfortunately, and the mascara didn't show itself when I wiped my eyes with a tissue. It applies a bit clumpy, but I recently learned that using a clean lash brush to separate my lashes after application really helped. The mascara doesn't sting my eyes nor crumble into my eyes. It was easy to remove as long as your makeup remover can do a good job with waterproof makeup. :)