Stays put

If your are looking for an eyeliner that is smudge proof and water proof you've come to the right place! I use this eyeliner if I now it will be super hot and humid outside so that I know it will stay on. I also have worn it to the pool and have come home to see that my eyeliner is still in place! It's easy to apply and glides easily across your skin. It comes in a ton of colors so you are sure to find your perfect shade. I bought mine at Sephora and it was a bit expensive but I wanted a waterproof eyeliner from a high quality and reputable brand so I chose Makeup Forever and highly recommend this.

This has been my holy grail in eyeliner! it's super easy to apply, goes on really smooth and stays put for hours! I was told by a employee at Sephora that they were made for synchronized swimmers so it's SUPER waterproof. She was right! My eyes get watery really often (especially when I wear my contacts) and this is the only eyeliner that stays for way longer than an hour. Ive tried both the crayon and the liquid liner. I liked the pencil ways more, mostly because i can't apply liquid liner without looking like a clown but i also found that it was a bit watery. i had to go over more than once to get a good opaque black line. I have also tried multiple colors, they're all AMAZING!

This is the only pencil eyeliner I have ever tried that does not smudge. It goes on smoothly, even just above the lash line. It also has a large array of colours. It is superb.

This eye liner looks amazing when you put it on and it just glides on you dont have to go over and over an area to make it look dark

I was looking for a long lasting, black eyeliner and this one was recommended to me by a sales associate at Sephora. Its more expensive then what I typically spend but well worth every penny! It glides on smooth, doesn't pull at the skin, long lasting and doesn't smudge. Goes on dark as well so don't have to keep reapplying.

This is my new love!

This is one decent waterproof and smudge proof pencil liner. It stays on without smudging for more than 6 hours for me considering I have very oily eyelids. The usual waterproof pencil liner usually smudge within 3 hours and it sometimes irritate my eyes since i wear contact lenses but this one works fine. It goes on smoothly allowing you to draw very thin lines. It works very well for under eyes too, doesn't smudge easily but after a whole day, it will leave u with a little bit of panda eyes which is fine for me.

Besides all that, it also comes in a lot of colors!

For the price, it's worth every single penny. I rather spend $20 on an eyeliner which I only need to apply once a day and not have to worry about it creasing then paying $10 for something that will smudge and crease and requires constant touch ups!

This eyeliner definitely delivers, I have a lot of problems with transfer of color when I wear eyeliner even with waterproof eyeliners. This one is great it stays on without smudging and there is no transfer. My only problem with is that I can't find a large selection of colors for it, but that might be just the sephora I shop at.

Again MUFE has wowed me again. Aqua eyes is waterproof, smudge proof and will stay put for a whole day without fading or creasing. I have a problem with oily eyelids which cause a lot of eyeliners to settle at the the bottom of my eyes at the end of the day but this one doesn't budge for the entire day :) The price is steep but it will definitely last you at least a year (it's one of those pencils you sharpen) so I find it totally worth it. Yay MUFE!

Ladies.... I think I've found a new love.

Make Up for Ever Aqua Eyes. Greatest. eyeliner. ever! I have the one in Pearly Brown 2L.

It does not fade, budge, or run underneath your eyes. It is completely waterproof, until you remove it with eye make up remover. The trick is that you have to wait for a few seconds to let it set. Once it's on, it's on for good! I seriously think that it is the perfect eyeliner for those who have teary eyes or .... to wear to a wedding or a funeral. It won't smudge at all. Try it yourself!

The only thing that I am a little bit uncertain about is that it appears to need sharpening quite often. It's not a very "hard" tip, but yet... so worth it!

I know $18 is really expensive for an eyeliner, but I am so pleased with the results. I will definitely buy this again.