Perfection

I had been sent this from Glamour Beauty Club to try. This gel liner gives the perfect line and can go in close to the top lashes, meaning that you can create a thick or thin line depending on how you feel. It can be applied to the waterline and can be used to tightline creating the look of ticker, fuller lashes. I had worried that it would irritate my eyes as some liners have done in the past. This didn’t. It is waterproof and came off easily with the Curél Gel Cleanser that I am currently using. I believe that the full-size crayon has a built-in sharpener in order to keep he perfect shape. It is a shame that the smaller size doesn’t have the sharpener as it would be useful in order to keep the shape of the tip of the crayon. I would like to try (Stone) Fox 58 – a metal grey or Plum(age) 60 – a vivid purple.

Expensive

This eyeliner is nice. It goes on smooth and dark. The packaging is nice looking. But very expensive. You can find similar quality and even better stuff at the drugstore

I had such high hopes!

I honestly had such high hopes for this product. However, applying the liner was extremely difficult to do, in fact a majority of the pigment broke off after trying to applying to my eyes (during the first use!) This really isn't worth your time or money! It was such a disappointment.

Probably Wouldn't Get This Again

This eyeliner is pretty expensive. It is creamy and a good dark black shade, but I have found cheaper ones for the same quality at the drugstore. I would rather spend my money on a creamier eyeliner from the drugstore than repurchase this brand again. If the price isn't a problem for you, then it is a good eyeliner!

long lasting

MAKE A BOLD STATEMENT WITH THIS EXTREME-WEAR, WATERPROOF EYELINER. LIKE A GEL POT EYELINER ENCASED WITHIN A CRAYON, THIS BREAKTHROUGH FORMULA IS EXCLUSIVE TO MARC JACOBS BEAUTY: A SUPER-MALLEABLE GEL EYELINER GLIDES ON SMOOTHLY FOR A FLAWLESS, PRECISE APPLICATION, THEN SETS IN PLACE FOR ALL-DAY WEAR. A BUILT-IN SHARPENER HELPS MOLD PRODUCT INTO A PERFECT POINT FOR AN INSTANTLY SHARP LOOK.

just a brand name product, didn't like

I received the product from Sephora and was excited to try, as it was considered a "fashion" brand gone to makeup.
I did not like.

The crayon was difficult to put on precisely, it would smudge a lot, which is good if you want a smudged smokey look, but not for an every day or delicate precise eye liner look.

The color was good but didn't last all day, honestly especially in the summer color faded fast, and needed frequent application.

The eyeliner was extremely difficult to sharpen!!!!!!!

Overall, fashion brand should tick to marc jacobs what does best and leave crayon to other makeup brands.

Didn't work for me

Received a deluxe size of this and was very excited to use it. This is the blackest black eye liner I've ever used, BUT it tugs and skidds on my eyelids instead of gliding. There's also very little product for the price. Pretty heart broken

I finally found the one!!!!

After years of trying I have finally found the perfect eye liner that will stay in place on my water line.
I could never find one that doesn't run or just doesn't stay in general.
Although it is pricey it is 100% worth it and will last forever.... don't even question if you want it... you need it

Only eyeliner that stays in place

I received this as a birthday present from sephora and had no expectations. But it's awesome, easy to apply, nice black color and is the only eyeliner that stays in place and not end up under eyes. Thumb up!

Impressed

Upon receiving these as a complimentary sample, I used them as shadow bases and you have to work quick with them before they dry or else they stay the way you applied it. I was impressed with how long they stayed in place. This is the first gel pen that doesn't crease or run.