Its an Ok product, I can't say that is horrible but its not what I was looking for. But will say that it opened by mind to other possibilities and I found the best solution which was a brand new product called Albolene eye makeup remover. I would have posted this review there if chick advisor had a spot for me to write a review. Anyways, its paraben free and made with jojoba oil which made it stand out because I went home and started looking up products that had ingredients that I loved. It conditioned my eye lashes and made me realize how easy it can to remove waterproof mascara, which it still was a struggle with Marcelle. Anyways, I wouldn't buy this product again, but I would love to write a review for Albolene eye makeup remover!! Chick Advisor, help me out! :)