It gets the job done but can be a little hard to work with.

I love this liner in black. It is so pigmented and so easy to use. I tried to eggplant one, and it was the greatest. The product was too dry to even come on the brush. But by far, the black is amazing.

I found this to be a good eyeliner, however, it's not 100% smudge proof as people with oily eyelids will have this smudge off pretty quick. I use this for a winged-line look and it's not bad. I only wished this stayed on longer than 30 mins.

I love the effect this gel liner has on the eyes. It is easier to apply than liquid liner and more striking than pencil liner. It also doesn't smudge. The only problem was that I was using it simultaneously while using pencil liner (for the day time) so I did not use the Gel Liner fast enough and I felt after a while it started to dry out.
One tip I would give is invest in a good brush for application and clean it after every use as the gel hardens on the brush.

This was the first gel eyeliner i have ever purchased! I love it so much that i use it everyday. Its very black, creamy and go on so smooth, Its a little bit pricey for drugstore you can get for about 10$ but it worth every penny;)

I absolutely love this eyeliner. It lasts forever. As in, I can wear it all day, go to sleep and wake up in the morning and it's only a little smudged. I also like how it stays dark, as some blacks are more grey than black. It's also easy to make wings with the brush included.

Awesome, was unsure how well it would work when I first tried it, but I was amazed on how great it works and stays and how easy it is to use!

No the best for hooded eyes - I found that this eyeliner smudged with time. There's better eyeliners out there!

Love it!! Goes on very smooth and black, lasts all day and stays in place.

I think that product is good for your lower line, Last all day,