I purchased my Maybelline eyeliner from Walmart only two weeks ago. I opened it the day after my purchase and I was super disappointed. I don't know what the exact source of the problem was but my line just doesn't seem to stay. If I go over the same line twice, the brush seems to pick up the first application and leaves a clear uncolored area on my eyelid. Another thing I noticed was that the container itself seemed fairly dry. Whenever I pull out my brush from the bottle or lightly pump it back into the bottle for more liner liquid, it seems as if the brush is not really absorbing any liquid at all. Could it be that there is little or no liquid in the bottle itself? There is a bonus feature to this product though. I am able to shake the bottle for the ball inside to roll around. I am assuming this means the liner liquid would not be dried up and actually be mixed whenever I shake the bottle. Well, the ball feature is a nice touch but it seems pointless when there is no liquid to start out with.

The Maybelline NY Line Stiletto Ultimate Precision Liquid Eyeliner is one of the best drugstore liquid liners I have used. Even with light makeup on, I always make sure to put on eyeliner just to make the eyes pop even more and I was very impressed at how great this liner is.

To be honest, when I first bought this product, I was a little skeptical at how well it will work. After a week of using it, it's found a permanent space in my make-up bag.

The packaging is great. You get 1.5ml of the product and comes with a very thin and tapered felt-tip applicator. The applicator glides on very smoothly and you get a more shiny finish instead of a matte finish. The applicator also comes with a long handle which makes for an easier grip and better control when applying the product. Because the applicator is so thin, you can get very precise thin lines but you could also build towards more dramatic looks by applying more.

It's long-lasting and doesn't smudge nor does it flake off, yet still easy to remove. Touch-ups are very easy with this liner. I often go over the liner after applying my mascara and the thin applicator allows me to do that easily.

It's extremely affordable and works wonderfully. Overall, it's a great buy. I would highly recommend this product and for sure I'll be purchasing it again.

I like this liner, I use it when I want to give myself a bold liner look. I like how easily it glides on and how crisp a line it gives I wouldn't recommend it for anyone who doesn't have a steady hand though, the brush/liqued is not the most user friendly.

LOVE LOVE LOVE! My favorite eyeliner in the world. Perfect application every time I use it. I am able to apply a clean line with no smudging or running. Allows me to have dramatic or classic looks. Drys in no time. Allow me to get super close to the lash line.

Possibly my favorite liquid eyeliner ever. The brush is perfect and really good for precision. I have in black and the color is VERY black. It lasts all day and does not flake at all. In short, it's just perfect!

I love wearing eye liner since I was 18 but thought what a pain in the butt it was applying it before. I had probably the most difficult ones that were given to me for free so I might as well used them up since I love wearing it. Finally ended up purchasing my own wen I was done with them and tried Maybelline NY Line Stiletto wen it first came out since it stood out because they had them hanging like in a red box display and I was in a rush too so I grabbed one of those to not have to go through the isles looking for one. I ended up liking it, I don't take almost an hour struggling, I'm serious...trying to get both eyes to look the same and doing the tip. Now I got the hang of it more and the felt tip makes it pretty easy to apply and I get it done quick too. I would buy this eyeliner again if I don't see another one that I would like to try to compare.