I received this product from the Shopaholic Movie Night Swag Bags. Wow, when they say unstoppable, they certainly mean it. I used this before a night out, and it lasted the whole night, and even after I (shamefully) didn’t wash my face before I went to bed, it hadn’t budged by the morning. It was still literally PERFECT. I was super impressed. However, as great as being smudgeproof and waterproof as, I don’t care for it when it comes time to wash it off – it does not wash off with my regular cleanser, and I don’t want to buy a make-up remover just to remove this one product (I rarely use enough eye make-up to constitute buying remover…) My only other complaint is that it is one of those “self-sharpening” types of eyeliner, which I never really care for because I prefer to sharpen the my eyeliners to the finest point possible, so this one doesn’t really cut it.

Overall, I would recommend this product for its staying power and smudge proof abilities, but not for its waterproof-ness (because honestly, how many times do you really need your eyeliner to stay on when you go swimming??? Ha ha ha)