I really like this sunscreen. I used it for a week at the beach, on the beach every day. It goes on very easily, not thick like the Sport 50 I had been using. It has almost no fragrance. It did not wash off while I was in the ocean. I did not burn at all. I don't know about Consumer Reports, but this is the best sunscreen I have ever used and I would highly recommend it. I also noticed that Walmart is now selling it again.