I bought this product because I read in Allure magazine that it was the best eye makeup remover. The first few times I used it, I though it was just "average". What I expect from an eye makeup remover is that it eliminates all of my mascara and eye shadow and whatnot is one swipe. This was not the case with this product. I also found that the individual cotton pads stuck together and I ended up using 3 at a time because I just couldn't pry them apart. Towards the end of the jar, the pads took on a yellow-ish tint. When i finally got to the end, I realized that RUST from the metal container was starting to react with the eye makeup remover formula. SO DISGUSTING! Never buy this product. I'm surprised that I can still see after using rust-infused eye makeup remover pads on them. So bad...