This is the worst eyeliner I have ever tried. The ink dries on the brush before it even touches your eyelid. You need to completely soak your brush in order to have enough product, and if you think you're going to go over the same spot more than once, you're wrong - trying to add more only takes away what you've already applied. This stuff crumbles and flakes like nobody's business. I've tried every brush/method I can think of and nothing has worked. The colors are beautiful, but the quality is trash. This was the biggest waste of money I have ever spent.