I've tried many different eye make up removers but consistently come back to this one. It is effective, gentle and never irritates my skin.

I really like this product. It's great for sensitive skin and I wear contacts and doesn't irritate my eyes like some eye makeup removers do. The smell is pleasant and a little bit goes a long way. Haven't tried it with waterproof mascara yet but I'm sure it will do just as well

I have tried several make-up removers and always go back to this. It removes my mascara and my lashes feel softer. I also like that the product does not use animal testing.

This is the makeup remover that I use regularly. I usually use it only to remove the excess makeup after I shower though, so it really doesn't have to work very hard. I find that it has a hard time removing my waterproof mascara, but I like that it is gentle on my eyes and doesn't leave a residue.

I use a lot of Body shop products for face and body, because they always have sales going on, and I like their products in general. This make up remover does its job fairly well with regular mascara, however, I found it a little bit hard to remove my water proof mascara. It does removes the rest of the eye makeup fine (eyeshadow and so on).

It is not drying, or leave an oily film, if you don't like that. Just be careful not to get it in your eye, because it really stings.

I use this sometimes, especially when I have more eye makeup on because of its creamy texture/

This is the most gentle make up remover that I have tried which is great for sensitive skin. Mascara is a little more difficult, however, it is still my favourite that I've tried so far! It smells mild and is a great way to finish off the day.

This makeup remover is great at removing liquid or pencil eyeliner, eye shadow and lips... however it took me a couple times to remove my mascara. Besides that it's a very mild formula which doesn't sting the eyes or area around the eye. It's not oil based so it doesn't leave a residue on your skin. An overall okay makeup remover.

I bought this strictly based on it's claim of gentle formula and bottle size/price.

It works well on all products that aren't over sparkly or water resistant/waterproof.

Bottom line: there are better products out there, but this is a big bottle for a pretty decent price ($11?)