We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
101-120 of 1577

Revlon Matte Eye Shadow

7 reviews

I'm not sure if you can still even purchase these shadows -- they may have been discontinued. I only have this in the lightest shade, 001 Vintage Lace. You get 2.4g but the price varies depending on where you purchase it (just Google it). In my experience, these shadows are very...
Urban Decay Show Pony Shadow Box

1 review

The Urban Decay Show Pony Shadow Box contains six highly pigmented and shimmery shadows, an almost full size Urban Decay 24/7 glide-on eye pencil in Zero, and a mini UDPP all nicely packaged in clear plastic. The colors from top left to right in order are: Snatch, Mildew, Flash...
Cargo Hands of Hope Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

I received this product to review from Cargo Cosmetics. I haven't been a big eye shadow user for several years, but this palette may just be the product to convert me back to the beauty junkie that I was in high school! I have only used about half of the colours so far...
Trucco Eye Shadow

1 review

THIS IS AN AWESOME PRODUCT, WITH THE LATEST OF TREND COLOURS. IT IS AS PROFESSIONAL LINE WHICH YOU CAN BUY IN THE SALON. I AM LOOKING FOR A CANADIAN SUPPLIER, SO IF YOU HAVE ANY INFORMATION, IT WILL BE APPRECIATED
GOSH Cosmetics Duet Eye Shadow

6 reviews

These are really good quality eyeshadows and I got mine on sale so it wasn't too expensive!
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Eyeshadow Quad

183 reviews

This product glides on like butter, super blendable and highly pigmented. I would recommend you buy this over any over priced shadow. These work best compared to all those out there.
Cargo Dare To Play Eye Kit

2 reviews

i bought this because i loved the colors. in the morning i dont have alot of time to get ready so when i bought this it was great its everything i need all in one cute pink box. there are sooo many color combos and if you are new to the whole make up thing is fool proof all the...
Too Faced Glamour To Go 2 Pocket Palette

1 review

I really like this eyeshadow palette, this palette is a matte version and I really like the subtle and natural colors. Also includes 8 eyeshadows, 4 lip gloss and one blush and for the price is unbeatable. I really like the color that I could mix and match with different...
Clinique Touch Base For Eyes

3 reviews

This is one of my favorite eye products. It's great to wear on its own sometimes for a super low-key day. Definitely gives super staying power to my eye shadow when worn as a base. No creasing and everything sticks where it should all day long. Worth every penny!
Sigma Makeup Beauty On The Go Kit in Neutral Shades

1 review

These eyeshadow palettes are such a steal for what you get. Instead of getting a palette with four eyeshadow already in it, you get a compact case with a huge mirror (woot!), and 4 individual eyeshadow that includes a tiny applicator and mirror. To use these palettes, you simply...
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 3 Kit Eye Shadow - Shimmering Sands

7 reviews

This is such an amazing trio of eyeshadows - neutral, but with just a hint of shimmer that really draws attention to the eyes - it looks really good with my green eyes, and the eyeshadow quality is pretty good - doesn't crease (apply a primer). , silky feel, and goes on easily...
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers in Swiss Chocolate

4 reviews

I was really happy with this eye shadow,loved the color, it went on smoothly, stayed on for hours,very impressed,love cover girl products
Vasanti Cosmetics The Hamptons Eye Palette

3 reviews

I have recently started using Vasanti products because they are a new brand, and I have to say that I really love what they make. This palette can be a little pricey considering it only comes with 5 colors and is a small palette but the quality of the pigmentation is real! They...
Everyday Minerals Eyeshadow in Cliche

1 review

A nice base eyeshadow for an everyday metallic sheen to the eyes. It is a light grey/silver colour. Don't let that frighten you though, it is actually very light and not over the top at all. I like applying it as a base and then lining my top lip with pencil eyeliner...
Urban Decay Sustainable Shadow Box

1 review

This palette is a nice one, i wouldn't say it is my favorite but urban decay is a wonderful brand. It's very pigmented and very fun to play with. My only down fall about it is all the sparkle in it, as you put it on your eyelids a whole bunch of the sparkle fall out...
tarte cosmetics Flower Child Natural Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

Designed by makeup artist Tina Turnbow, this eco friendly eyeshadow palette is perfect pop of colour of spring. With 10 different eyeshadow colours, there are multiple looks (day or night) that can be created. Also included is an eye primer, double ended eyeshadow brush and...
Manly 120 Professional Eyeshadow Palette #1

2 reviews

I know the Coastal Scents palette is popular right now but this Manly palette is giving CS a run for their money! First of all, this product is sold exclusively through eBay but ranges from $20 to $50, depending on shipping, blah, blah, blah. I've played around with this...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Eye Transformer Eye Shadow

2 reviews

Target woman beware! I went to target when i was told by elf that there products were on sale, what i sale ugh i didnt know 4 dollars for there normal dollar products was a steal honestly there eye transformer is average it would have been better had the price been lower in...
Thierry Mugler Regard Stellaire Eye Shadow Quad in Blue Rhapsody

2 reviews

This is one of the best eye shadows I have ever used and the colour is breath taking so beautiful if you haven't tried it then you must no regrets for me.
Urban Decay Ammo Shadow Box

11 reviews

This is probably my favorite palette!! Urban Decay eyeshadows rock to begin with... And this palette offers a great arrangement of colors. They are all very pigmented and beautiful. I use the white one as a highlighter on just the peak under my brow. I actually bought a second...