I bought this a long time ago in Onyx and i love how the pigment is so rich and black.

As a Liner I only used it as powder form not liquid so eyeliner wise .....
Pros:
-it was super black (just the way i liked it)
-looked natural wen I applied it as a powder liner
-Lasted a very long time (1 and a half years since i bought it)

Cons:
-messy
-creased very easily
-the container - the holes were too big so theres always so much product

Eyeshadow wise...

Pros:
-easily blendable
-so much pigment

Cons:
-it took me a while to get used to the fact that its so pigmented

I wear contacts and it doesnt irritate it

recommended for people who know how to use it