I did not love it. And I wanted to love it. Maybe it is because I am not very good at putting on eyeliner but I found it very difficult to use. I found the liner itself hard to control and that is came out pretty chunky. I thought it was hard to control and smudged easily. Disjointed and disappointed. And the price is high!

I bought the Benefit They're Real Push-Up liner with high hopes for it and was unfortunately terribly let down. I just want to say first of all the I love the liner itself. It has a good consistency is jet black and dries fairly matte which is what I was looking for BUT the packaging ruined it for me.

When you click it up you waste ALOT of product . The applicator is flimsy and very difficult to work with and I feel like for the price and the hype it should have worked better.

I do still use the gel liner itself but I use it with my own brush and still waste a lot of product. I love Benefit as a company but unfortunately this was a miss for me .

It is difficult to apply and remove. It smears. Not good for oily skin.

I do not really recommend this product, it just was not for me. The formula itself isn't terrible but the rubbery applicator tip, to me, made it harder to apply a neat line.

I am a HUGE fan of Benefit and have nearly their entire line! I was super excited for this gadget and it just turned out to be a gimmick. I thought I had hit the jackpot after watching the videos because up to this point I wasn't able to create a good winged liner consistently. The first time I used it, I was blown away...quick, easy, flawless winged eye! When I went to use it a second time, I had trouble getting the product to come up and when it did, it would just crumble. I wasn't able to get a smooth defined line...it was just really disappointing overall...I wasted so much product. No matter how much you think this product will work, it won't. Don't buy it!

I bought this eye liner because of the dramatic results on the packaging and because it was advertised as being very easy to use. The quality itself was very high and it was a thick and creamy consistency but it was no easier to use than other products and I managed to smear myself with quite a bit of it before getting a straight line.

This might be suitable for people who are very good at applying eye liner but for me, the high price point made this not worth buying. Plus the stay-put formula meant it was hard to correct my mistakes although I can see how that would be a plus for other people.

I would basically say that this product is great for a beginner, or someone who lacks a steady hand. It's not a horrific product by any means, you just need to work with it and learn how to use it. I also does not work for everyone. I like to use it to give me the defined perfect wing to my liner, but I will just line my eye with a normal gel/liquid liner and use this to do the flick at the end.

To see more reviews & photos please visit amysbeautydiary.weebly.com!

Do not attempt to use this eye liner if you are an average makeup user like me. I think it looks nice but you definitely have to practice. You need a steady hand. I found that it didn't come out easily, I had to keep twisting and then it would clump, I think I'll stick to my pencil. But if you are courageous, do it!

From the brand benefit, I expected a great product. This was not great. It was akward to handle and use, didn't come out flowing and for the price I was pretty disappointed.
And it took forever to get off as well which sucked.

It takes a bit to get used to. If you push too much up, you get clumps and crappy lines, I'm still working on it. But when I get it right it's a good thing!