This liner is like no other. It is gel in form of a tube. Perfect and easy for winged lines! The only downside is you have to be careful when twisting for more product. If you get too much it will clump and fall out, making your eyeliner application messy, especially if you are midst application! But I would def repurchase.

It is the best liner I have ever tried and I've tried them all! Its a lil expensive but the way it goes on smooth as thick or thin as you want and it holds up your lashes it's well worth it!!

Amazing and long lasting really precise

Goes on easy, perfect shade of black! Last all day, easy to apply!

I am definitely a fan of this liner. I think that a common misconception, however, is that it'll be easy to use on your first try -- heads up, this will probably not be the case for most of us! It takes practice to get used to manoeuvring this liner; there's definitely a learning curve here! I found that I had to practice and play with it a few times before I was able to get the perfect cat eye down pat. But now that I have gotten used it it, I'm loving this! I've even been getting more compliments on my eyes lately! I love that this liner comes on very opaque -- once you've gotten the proper technique down, there's no need to retrace your lines multiple times! In fact, I actually try to avoid doing this because I find that it makes the liner more likely to flake off. Also, another tip -- make sure you clean off the tip before each use. This will ensure that you don't have old, gross product that's hardened coming off on your eyes! Also, this product can be pretty difficult to get off (which is, unfortunately, a big con) so you really have to make sure that you're uber careful when you're applying it, so that you don't end up making a mistake. However, overall, despite this and the fact that it's expensive, it's definitely one of the better liquid eyeliners I've tried, so I would repurchase this :)! I love the way it makes my eyes pop.

This eyeliner is my absolute favourite! It looks amazing and really makes my eyes pop! I love how matte it is! The only issue with this product is that it takes a lot of getting used to. It's extremely difficult to put on at first, but once you get used to it, its amazing!

I have been hearing a lot about this liner from about everyone in the beauty world. I finally got my hands on it and was excited to try. I love the whole idea of the cream liner in the form of a pencil. The formula itself is so black and its staying power is impeccable. The only thing that I have to say about it that is less than desirable is simply the fact that then you first use it (everytime) the top of the liner is a little dry, so it clumps up in a ball on your lashline. the you have to clean it out, and it is simply tedious and wasteful on product. I still do recommend it , it is such a good liner!

My new Favourite gel liner! Waterproof, does not smudge and even though its hard to remove at times its all worth it :)

When this liner came out I knew I had to try it! I have been a big fan of Benefit for years and a liner user for basically ever. I am glad to report that it was worth all the hype! This liner is innovative, easy to use, and has mucho staying power! Once you get the hang of the flexible tip, creating a straight line is very simple and for those of us who rock the cat eye more often than not, it's definitely worth the price! I get a perfect line every time!