I recently ran out of my Loreal Voluminous mascara and was in the make up isle at walmart i decided to try the extra volume collagen mascara in blackest black and of course waterproof.

This mascara claims to "...enhance the thickness of your lashes for up to 12X more impact without the clumps...."

That did not prove itself at all. This is an aweful mascara. That clumps and flakes more than any I have ever tried before. This by far is the worst.

After applying one coat I noticed no change. Then with the second coat there was extreme clumping and it did not go on easily. It added no volume and my lashes just seemed to stick together. I would definately not recommend this mascara.

I think I will stick to my Loreal Voluminous mascara. That is the best ever and it has never proved me wrong. :)