These eyeshadows are great. I bought the one called forgiving.
I'll be honest, I have a really hard time with eyeshadow and rely on expensive brands to help me. I wear Lancome, I figured I would try a L'Oreal brand eyeshadow in lieu of Lancome (L'Oreal owns Lancome, so they make similar products)
My lids are oily ( I'm saving for a primer) but at the end of the day held up well.

I'm glad I did. I will repurchse.

What I like about it:
The eyeshadows not only the colors are perfectly paired-up and pretty, they are also increadibly pigmented. The swatches you're looking at are applied once WITHOUT a base. It shows up in one swipe. The eyeshadows didn't feel chalky, but it was soft like butter! The texture actually reminded me of Veluxe Pearl eyeshadows from MAC. All colors are also wearable whether it be by day or night. Use the lighter side for everyday looks, and by night smoke it up with the darker side. The glitters or reflects on the darker side are not chunky or insanely glittery. It's just enough to complement its partnering color. The eyeshadows also blended really well and easily. And what's not to like about the price? For $7-8 a pop, you get two eyeshadows! It's even better with the BOGOF deal (all 4 shadows equaling ONE MAC eyeshadow)!

Oh, and as someone has pointed out, the deep plum shade in the Sculpted duo is a dupe for MAC's Beauty Mark. That's one eyeshadow less you have to get from MAC and at a cheaper price.

What I don't like about it:
You can't depot it :(. I like my eyeshadows depotted, but that's just my personal preference. Very limited color selection since there are only five eyeshadow duos available. I had some trouble opening the packaging, but that's some minor detail. Other than that, I can't think of any!

Overall:
I will definitely purchase more on this line if more colors become available! It's probably my favorite drugstore makeup right now because of it's quality and price.