I saw Tati on youtube recommending this and since she is a makeup professional, I had really high hopes for this eyeliner. Sadly, the pigmentation is very low, which is quite deceiving. I saw people here saying that you have to turn it upside down, which I did but it didn't change anything. The biggest pro of this is its price, I bought it at Walmart for around 3$. I didn't try it yet on my eyes so I'll probably keep it and only wear it for a natural makeup look. Hope this review helped!