2.7/5
6 reviews
NYC Big bold and precise felt tip eyeliner Reviews
#345 in Eye Liner

    Reviews and Ratings

    50% OF CHICKS DIG IT

    3.3/5
    Value

    Quality

    Effectiveness

    Recommended? You Betcha!
    June 21, 2017

    My first eyeliner

    Honestly, I wasn't expecting much with this liner but it wasn't bad. It is easy to use, applies rather smoothly and easily but it is not that pigmented. To achieve a solid black, you would have to go back and forth with the felt tip on your eye which could also make you more prone to mistakes if you spend that much time on one eye.

    It also has this really chemically smell but you get used to it after a while.

    The eyeliner doesn't smudge though but by no means is it water-resistant. If you rub it a few times, it will smudge. But if you just leave it without touching your eye, you should be fine for the day.

    I recommend this for eyeliner beginners because the felt tip is great for precision and control, the wearability is decent, the liner itself is pretty inexpensive compared to other liners and it doesn't irritate the eyes.

    Flag as Spam Flag as Spam
    5.0/5
    Value

    Quality

    Effectiveness

    Recommended? You Betcha!
    March 07, 2017

    This is the best eyeliner around! Forget anything else, this stays on, goes in smooth and the price is unbeatable! Much better than the more expensive liners that don't stay on

    Flag as Spam Flag as Spam
    1.0/5
    Value

    Quality

    Effectiveness

    Recommended? Fugheddaboutit!
    October 13, 2016

    I bought this eyeliner because it's a nice short stick which is easier for me to use since I'm pretty much blind. I expected it to do what it says, be big and bold, it's nowhere near. It's watery, washed out and useless. Don't buy. I've sent an email to the company to see if they will rectify the issue, which may increase my rating, especially if it turns out that this tube is a fluke.

    Updated On: March 06, 2017

    I want to update this review, and it's a little long in the making. I contacted the company regarding my disappointment in this product and they were FANTASTIC! They responded quickly, apologising for the eyeliner not being the big and bold black and they sent me a brand new one to replace the old one. Granted when I tried the new one, it was blacker but not as bold as I was looking for. However, I discovered that if you store these with the tips down, you get that big bold black look you're looking for. With all of that in mind, storing the product with the tips down and the timely and helpful response of the company, I would increase this to a 3 out of 5. Now just to get the hang of the tip!

    Flag as Spam Flag as Spam
    4.3/5
    Value

    Quality

    Effectiveness

    Recommended? You Betcha!
    June 28, 2016

    The larger tip of this pen is great for a thicker line. Its angled tip also makes application very easy. You can use it horizontally for a thinner, bold line or vertically for an extra-thick line. The product goes on the lid very nicely and looks dark and bold, the way you want it. If you make a mistake while applying, it's easy to get off with a q-tip which also means that if you're going to wear it all day it might end up darkening your lid but that's only after a whole day. Otherwise it stays where you put it and looks wonderful.

    Flag as Spam Flag as Spam
    2.2/5
    Value

    Quality

    Effectiveness

    Recommended? Fugheddaboutit!
    February 12, 2016

    I really did not like this eye liner at all! I'm so upset this purchase wasn't as good as it was promising. The felt tip is too thick. It doesnt have a narrow enough slant of the tip. Don't waste your time on the one even for it being under $4. I will be using it for face painting with the kids! bummer.

    Flag as Spam Flag as Spam
    0.5/5
    Value

    Quality

    Effectiveness

    Recommended? Fugheddaboutit!
    January 13, 2016

    I couldn't find my usual eye liner and this one was on sale and I was willing to try something new. WHAT A MISTAKE! This product was like a really weak, cheap marker that barely worked. It only hurt my eyes while trying to put it on and it wouldn't actually leave any color on my eyes. It somewhat marked my skin but it was just horrible. Don't even bother trying this one.

    Flag as Spam Flag as Spam

    These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.