We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
41-60 of 1577

e.l.f liquid metallic eyeshadow

1 review

I’m obsessed with this liquid eyeshadow stick. The color is seriously stunning and subtle but makes your eyes SHINE. I thought it would be too bold and party-like, but I’ve been wearing it during the day and have gotten so many compliments. It’s like a golden champagne...
Smashbox Eye Shadow Cover Shot Eye Palette

33 reviews

The best colours. I like the neutral palettes always goes on smooth, and never cakes or creates dust. I love this shadow and have several of them that I use all the time.
Juvia’s Place Rebal Honey

1 review

This four pan shadow palette is a perfect daytime or night time color story. The formula is super pigmented and smooth. The color lasts all day and will compliment any skin tone.
Tarte tartlet toasted eyeshadow

1 review

So beautiful. easy to blend and gives me perfect pigmentation . Perfect shades for day and night look, i use it almost daily. I love the orange and warm brown for my crease. It’s a must have palette for anyone who likes warm tone. Highly recommend.
Estate cosmetics eyeshadow juste a taste

1 review

Cette mini palettes de pigments Just A Taste contient quatre pastilles de couleurs neutres et ludiques. Il s’agit de poudre longue durée,sans cruauté animale,sans huile minérale,sans parabènes et végétalienne. La texture poudreuse de ces ombres à paupières leur...
Urban decay

1 review

Serving Looks 24/7. Vegan, Long lasting, Caffeine-Packed Shades. -Urban Decay Cosmetics These shadow sticks are really good on not budging when doing daily things or a night out. Shadow sticks are creamy but I found them a lil hard to blend. I'm gonna see if my fix it spray will...
Nude bynature

1 review

I love the texture of this eye shadow. It goes on creamy and flawlessly. The pigment is true to colour and long lasting. I will for sure be buying this again.
Violet Voss Fun Sized Mini Eyeshadow Palette Windflower

1 review

Perfect for travelling or keeping in your purse, this palette has 10 warm nude shades with pops of gold and copper. The colours are rich and pigmented, and I like the mix of mattes and shimmers. I’m never too adventurous when it comes to eyeshadows, and I believe this...
Melt Cosmetics Rust Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

I love how many different shades there are and the inclusion of matte AND shimmer to get that perfect look that just comes together. From light and creamy “Classic” to dark dramatic “Rott” and everything in between- this palette has it all.
at forest sight palette

1 review

This is great for just about any occasion! I love the shades, this has a good range of fun colors and neutrals. A little pigment goes a long way, and the payoff is great!!
L'Oreal Infallible Paints Eyeshadow

1 review

Blend, blend, blend. Do not indulge the impulse to glop this on like lipstick. Make a thin layer, of as many different tones as you like, and blend. Let dry. Then enjoy bold vibrant color ALL day, all night, however long you like. Once set, it doesn't budge, doesn't smear...
Morphe 9V Vintage Rose Palette

4 reviews

I really like this palette. The colours are so beautiful. They are a bit powdery but great to start with. Love the glitter shades. Perfect for everyday use.
Beauty Glazed Color Studio

3 reviews

Cette palette je l’avais acheté en me disant qu’elle allait me décevoir mais au contraire elle et supers je la rachèterais sans problème j’adore les différentes couleurs qui si trouve une seule couleur mais en plusieurs teintes variées j’adore cette palette et je...
Violet Voss Holy Grail

16 reviews

This palette may be somewhat pricey, but I’d say for the formula you definitely get what you’re paying for. Violet Voss’ shadows are extremely creamy and blend-able with gorgeous shades for a multitude of looks, definitely a staple palette for myself.
Maybelline Colour Strike Eyeshadow Pen

1 review

TikTok introduced me to this new eyeshadow phenomenon from Maybelline New York, they know about the latest beauty innovations and how to speed up superior make-up application so if I’m in need of a trend radiating make-up product at a drugstore price I go for MNY! Colour...
Too faced tutti frutti sparkling pineapple eyeshadow

1 review

this palette smells delicious 😋 The colors are beautiful and super pigmented, the colors is neutral. It only has two Matte shadows and the others are glitter and metallic, I love this palette and I'll be using it a lot 🌟
ColourPop Stone Cold Fox Palette

1 review

All of your neutral, cool toned smokey eye dreams will come true with this collection of smooth, powder eye shadow colours that have everything taupe, cosy brown and frosty deep cocoa shades and frosted grey-beiges to master any natural eye look from smoked out definition to the...
revolution 24K Gold Chocolate Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

I just discovered the revolution brand as I’ve been hesitant to try it. I am so impressed! This pallets is a bit different than the one named however it is a beautiful selection of eyeshadows and also multipurpose colours that I’ve tried for blush? bronzer, contour and even...
Burt's Bees Eyeshadow Trio - Evergreen Forest

1 review

Love the palette but not fussy about the price. It is $15 for this small palette. The formula is silky and smooth, very easy to blend and use. Good amount of pigment but isn't too pigmented. I am obsessed with the earthy colour story, it makes my eyes pop without being too dark...
XX Revolution Cosmology Palette

1 review

Enchanted new neutrals such as soft metallic golds, soft pinks, rosewood pearls and some matte shades mike soft browns are what XX Revolution Cosmology palette is all about, with the bigger pans serving as face contour and the smaller majority being eyeshadow. This doesn’t...