We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
81-100 of 1577

tarteist metallic eyeshadows

2 reviews

This pallet , the colors are adorable and easy to use, the formula and texture hasn't changed. They're stunning They're so creamy and buttery and the pigmentation is just beautifu I recommend
XX Revolution Karat Eyeshadow Palette

2 reviews

What can I say about these beautiful little palettes they're so good for the price and totally worth it I will never go back to another brand the shadows are creamy really high pigmented and look stunning together or on their own, of course would recommend this brand XX...
Rimmel Magnif’eyes Shadow Black

1 review

If you’re looking for a simple black eyeshadow this does the job. It blends well however is not as pigmented as I wanted it to be but for the price I paid it does well.
Urban Decay Naked Cherry Eyeshadow Palette

13 reviews

I’m a huge fan of Urban Decay Naked eye shadow palette however this one didn’t work for me. I found the colours in this palette didn’t work for my blue eyes and made me look washed out. It might work for brown eyes but not for mine. As always the shadow itself was great...
Flormar Sunset Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

I love the colors on it but for having the real tones, you have to put maybe 4 layers of powder. I use this one like a base. Nice texture, but it flies right away, its permanence is low.
PUR cosmetics eye shadow

1 review

I really like these eye shadows. Anytime I wear them I receive compliments, which doesn't happen when I've worn other mor expensive brands. I think their shimmery eyeshadows have more depth, and since they stay put so well and do not flake, they make a statement.
Hard Candy Look Pro Palette All that Roae Gold

1 review

I bought the all that rose gold from Hard Candy's look pro palette from the Walmart beauty section. The brand does not test on animals. It creates a nice shimmery finish to the eyelids. It is perfect for a party!
Hard Candy Glitteratzi Eyeshadow Duo

1 review

I bought this eyeshadow stick for dress up and end up loving it and put it on my lower eyelid as a cutesy goth look finish 🥰 I have 3 more colors and im not so fond of the iridescent end but the glitter is BITCHIN!
Jeffree Star Thirsty Eyeshadow Palette

9 reviews

I had received this palette in a Jeffree Star mystery box and was incredibly impressed. There's pilot is extremely expensive in Canada so I had never personally gone and picked it up myself. I have always wanted to try this palette as I've constantly seen it at the morphe store...
Beauty counter Eyeshadow

1 review

The eyeshadow went on soooooo buttery soft and it really delivered a lot of pigment upon the first application. The company boasts clean packaging and zero harmful ingredients.
Maybelline new york eye shadow lemonade craze

1 review

My favorite! Soft on skin , creamy, high pigment standing , love the colors could be used on daily basis. I use it as a highlighter too ;) Definitely worth money. I bought it like a year ago and still have some
Studiomakeup Endurance Eyeshadow Cream

1 review

This eyeshadow is a complete game changer to the way I wear my make up. I can add it on top of any eyeshadow to make it pop or wear it by along to give my lids a little sparkle. The more layers you use, the bolder the eyeshadow will show. It is a cream to dab on your eyelid and...
Morphe Eyeshadow Palettes 39L

3 reviews

I think out of all the eye palettes, this is my favorite based on price, quality and quantity. The array of colors is just fantastic, and they're vegan friendly. Love love love! The colors are highly pigmented
Stila Glitter and Glow liquid eyeshadow

21 reviews

I received the Stila Glitter & Glow Eye Shadow in Perlina in my Bloomingdales The Little Things The Eye Edit kit. The full size version retails at $24. The color Perlina is pretty and compliments my fair complexion and dark brown eyes. There wasn't much liquid eye shadow in the...
The Nubian by Juvia’s

1 review

I absolutely love this palette. The colors are really pretty. The only thing was the matte colors are a little less pigmented, but they definitely show up. The glitter colors are super pigmented and show up really well. This is definitely my go to palette.
morphe 9d palette

1 review

This palette is easily my favorite that I own. Eyeshadow is often expensive, but this works beyond any higher-end brand that I have used. The sunset colors in this are gorgeous! The shadows are buttery and blend effortlessly, and the pigment is jaw-dropping.
Elf Bite Size Eyeshadow in -Berry Bad-

3 reviews

I’m obsessed with this bite size pallet, very pigment and so convenient for travel, loved it so much that I purchased some of the other colours. The berry shades are so pretty and make my blue eyes pop
Covergirl Full Spectrum Eyeshadow

1 review

I have this Full Spectrum Covergirl eyeshadow and I am loving it! Neutral colors are my fave when it comes to eyeshadows and this palette is so my personality! It has 8 varieties of colors ranging from light brown to dark. Some of it also has glitters which I find it so cute.
Younique liquid eyeshadow

1 review

I use the color Giggly. Love this eyeshadow! I don’t wear eyeshadow very often and I’m not the best at applying it, but this makes things so easy! I just use the wand applicator and put on my eyelids. I then take my finger and blend it out. Blends like a dream! You can add...
Elizabeth Mott Smooth Shadow

1 review

I am so in love with this pencil combo. I received them in a subscription box a few months ago. The texture is so smooth it does not tug on the eye at all and it has a stay put formula that looks amazing. The medium fine tip allows me to create fine or thick lines. The shimmer...