We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
141-160 of 1577

Makeup Geek Secret Garden Duo-Chrome Eye Shadow

1 review

I think this is one of my favourite eye shadows of all time. It's a rich, emerald/forest green that shifts to a coppery brown or even a purplish-brown (depending on the colours around it). Easy to apply and looks best when applied with a finger over a wet base or glitter primer.
Tarte Rainforest of the Sea 3

12 reviews

Rainforest Of The Sea is a round shaped palette, with a pretty mermaid scale type design on outer housing and a mirror inside. It's like a pretty shell full of shimmering neutral eye shadow shades, yet no matte shades at all, so if you love pure pearl and shimmer shades this is...
Blue Blood palette

5 reviews

This palette is absolutely beautiful. It's a little pricey, but I really don't mind. As always Jeffree brought high quality, pigmented, buttery shadows to this blue themed palette. The pans a large, the packaging is beautiful, and the large mirror is always welcome. The...
Morphe Jaclyn hill pallette

2 reviews

I recently ordered this palette and was in love with this pallete.i love to play with these these really pigmented colours.cant wait to try different looks with this. Also I highly recommend this palette. Love love love this.give a try.i bet u won’t regret it.
Bellapierre shimmerroll

1 review

I really like this it is very easy to apply especially with having the roll on top. Very lovely colour and sparkle doesn’t last long have to re apply. If putting in eyes use a brush to put in eyes.
Younique Mineral Eye Pigments

38 reviews

These shadows are okay I guess.. I feel what what they are the price was ridiculous. They are kind of messy and the color payoff isnt the greatest. I can see why they were discontinued. They are nice and small so nice to put in your bag....
Naked basics pallet

25 reviews

I found nakeds makeup palettes to have a very odd texture. Though the colours of the product are amazing but till your don't have enough base and enough sticky material it hardly stays tidy
Morphe 15N Night Master Eyeshadow Palette

6 reviews

The colour story of this palette makes it a versatile addition to my collection. The deep tones allow for more dramatic Glam looks while the neutrals are great for everyday makeup. I find the shadows are of decent quality but do tend to have some fallout so don't dig in the pan...
Urban Decay Gwen Stefani Eyeshadow Palette

27 reviews

We all know we love a good dramatic eyeshadow look especially with the looks Gwen Stefani serves on a daily. Her eyeshadow palette Is so pigmented and beautiful colours. The only negative side is they are hard to blend together. Still worth the $ but make sure you take your...
Makeup Geek Day Dreamer Foiled Eye Shadow

1 review

Think about a regular shimmer eye shadow and then crank it up to 10. This light purple foiled shadow is intense. Use it over a wet base or glitter primer for even more intensity. I love it and wear it when I want a high shine shadow.
Stila shimmer and glow liquid eye shadow

4 reviews

These eye shadows are long-wearing, super shimmering and impressive on the eyes. I own three shades - Grace, Kitten and Starlight, and I enjoy every one of them. They are fuss-free, easy to apply and non-transfer. When in doubt, I always reach for them. The only issue is that...
Pat mcgrath mothership subliminal

1 review

This palette screams luxury. The beautiful black sleek packaging. And the amazing box it comes in. The shadows are soooo buttery and blend beautifully. Their extremely pigmented. The special shades are unlike any other.
The Balm Cosmetics Foiled Again - Red Handed

1 review

Really nice eyeshadow. It feels very smooth. Blends really well and is super shiny! Not much fallout. The box is super cute and looks great. Definitely recommend! Would be great as a small gift and stocking filler!
wet n wild Idol Eyes Cream Shadow Pencil

1 review

Loved the color. The price is very affordable. However, I found that product wasn’t long lasting. I didn’t use a eye shadow base, but didn’t think I needed to do so. I like this brand. Considering the price, the product is worth it.
Stila soul eyeshadow palette

2 reviews

I never hear anyone talking about this and I don’t understand why. The colour scheme is great. You can do multiple eye looks with this. They blend well and the pigmentation is on point.
Makeup Geek Stardust Shimmer Eye Shadow

1 review

This shadow is a soft white, maybe slightly champagne-hued shimmer eye shadow. Great inner corner highlight, good for adding light shimmer to the lid. Creamy and smooth
Colourpop-i think i love you palette

1 review

I love this palette. The colours scream fall. I used it all up. Great pigment and the shadows last all day. I mean all day. I definitely recommend this palette to anyone.
ColourPop Fame Palette

2 reviews

I recently started buying ColorPop Eyeshadows after I seen some hype online and after my bestie bought one for herself, and hyped it even more I had to buy one to try out. Tho pricey as it's USD I grabbed this pallette. It's so beautiful ❤️ the colors and pigment are...
Tarte  Maneater

1 review

Tarte Maneater Is a pallate of a mirror and eight eyeshadows that are in neutral colours. They blend in really well i have found that i can use them wet or dry. The colours are great for all ages and the colours stay on all night / day. I would really recomend tarte eye shadow
Essence Metal Shock Eyeshadow - Stars & Stories

1 review

Yet another cheap product from Shoppers Drug Mart that I fell absolutely in love with. I started with a gun metal grey and was just hoping it would go on the same color as it showed on the package and sure enough, so later on in the week I went back for another. This time I...