We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
61-80 of 1577

COVERGIRL Purple Eyeshadow Quad

6 reviews

Love this eye shadow goes on well heheh love that it don't flake or crease or crackmkn my eyes ,makes my Blue eyes really stand out.I got it as a gift for my birthday
L'Oreal Wear Infinite Eye Shadow Single

3 reviews

I was expecting more out this eyeshadow. The staying power was minimal (though I was not using a primer.) Despite getting a rich black colour, the colour payoff was slight and required a lot of application to be noticable. It creased over the course of the day and eventually...
Coastal Scents 88 Piece Makeup Palette

54 reviews

I remember getting this eye shadow palette for Christmas 1 year. I believe I still have it. The pigmentation is there but the size of the pans erk my nerves. If they pans were bigger than I wouldn't complain. It's great for a beginner though.
Mac Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Odd Couple

9 reviews

Did not last long enough, too sparkly. People rather buy their regular eyeshadows
Annabelle Cosmetics Custom Quad Compact

11 reviews

The eyeshadows sold in this quad are inexpensive, and very highly pigmented. I definitely recommend these eyeshadows. I have a gold shade, and it has the perfect amount of glitter that doesn't make my eyes look tacky.
AVON Triple Threat Cream Eyeshadow

2 reviews

I personally don't like this brand of eye shadow ,its messy and I found it didn't blend in very well and seemed to fade off very quickly the only good thing is it's inexpensive, there are alot of better shadows out there
Sephora Color Play Palette

2 reviews

Tres Bon rapport qualité prix, je Le recommande à tous. Ils y a du choix Et Le Produit tient bien.
Lise Watier Sea Belle Eye Shadow Quartet in Lagoon

3 reviews

Fard à paupières de texture fine et légère qui s'applique avec douceur pour un fini translucide ou opaque selon l'effet désiré.je le recommande a tous mes amis ,,,
Eye Enhancers 3-Kit Shadows in Firecracker

4 reviews

This is long lasting and I had gotten slot of compliments with this eyeshadow. You can use separately or together for a more dramatic look this is a great product
Lancôme Paris Color Design Sensational Effects Eye Shadow Quad

13 reviews

Love, love, love this eyeshadow! It's definitely worth every penny that I spent and I would definitely buy it again! It's nice and light feeling, with a pretty shimmer.
Annabelle Cosmetics Galaxy Eye Shadow Palette

3 reviews

I've had this palette for sometime. I'm not certain if it's a regular item or if it was a seasonal offering but I pull it out in the fall as it has nice brown, gold and reddish shadows that work well in the fall. the quality is as good as when I bought it and the shadows...
L'Oreal Paris HIP Metallic Duo

2 reviews

Found my old one while cleaning out all my makeup. They have a lot of fallout and just are kind of powdery
Maybelline Expertwear Eye Shadow Duo - Rose Tints

2 reviews

I have this product in 133 coral lily. (The colours are actually much lighter than they appear in the photo!) The apriocot colour goes on smoothly and it shows with one to 2 applications. The lighter colour takes more coats but it acts as a great eyebrow highlighter. I...
Bellapierre 9 Stack Eye Shadow

4 reviews

The Eye shadow 9 stack has lasted for years. You only need a tiny bit at a time. The colours are great and gives you a good selection to choose from. I don't really like the design of it. All 9 colours are stacked in a row. You need to be careful when unscrewing them or you...
Annabelle Cosmetics Mineral Pigment Dust

8 reviews

Ces pigment de chez Annabelle sont malade. Il n’en faut pas beaucoup pour donner une magnifique couleur sur les paupières. C’est en poudre mais pas trop poudreux.
Annabelle Cosmetics Single Eye Shadow

7 reviews

I use this as my base color. It’s super cheap and super versatile. There’s quite a few colors to choose from and the come in satin, metallic and chrome.
Rimmel London Color Rush Mono Eyeshadow

7 reviews

It's a decent eye shadow. I like shades they offer and this one works well for me. Doesnt last too long though.
Rimmel London Color Rush Trio Eyeshadow

7 reviews

Rimmel London Color Rush Trio Eyeshadow is very pigmented and the shades are pretty. The colours are easy to apply with your finger or with an applicator. The eyeshadow lasts all day and cleans off easily with cleanser and water.
Maybelline ExpertWear Eye Shadow Quad

2 reviews

I recently picked this shadow quad up from London Drugs. Good price (under $10) and quite a few shades to choose from. I decided on the one named "Styles Smokes" as I am a big fan of the smoky eye. I love all the shades and the how-to guide on the back. the colours last well and...
Avon mark I-Mark Eyeshadow

12 reviews

I have a small pallette with some wonderful colours. They have surprisingly good colour pay off for avon makeup! I used some of these shadows to do my makeup for a wedding and it lasted all night dancing without moving or creasing. I also like the sturdy packaging.