We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
181-200 of 1577

NUDESTIX Magnetic Eye Colour Pencil - Putty

2 reviews

Wow!! I got the colour Copper Foil in my February Boxycharm and i am in love!! The pigment behind this Eyeshadow crayon is bold & shimmery. Very easy to apply and lasts throughout the day. Doesnt crease or get greasy.
Maybelline Color Tattoo Eyeshadow - Tough as Taupe

1 review

I know this is a little odd but I don't use this product as eyeshadow- I use it as a brow gel. I am a natural blonde and always on the hunt for a good brow product. I get frustrated by a lot of "blonde" brow pencils and gels because they are so yellow toned. A fellow blondie...
Forever 21 nude palette

1 review

Can I just say WOW! I did not expect this product to turn out well, to be honest! It was actually pretty amazing and I went back for more! The pricing was very affordable and actually pretty cheap for the great quality! Just one swap and so much color appears! It was super...
Jordana Made to Last Liquid Eyeshadow

1 review

The shadow lasted 14 hours on my lids without any creasing; however, the color payoff did fade a bit as expected and with primer actually holds up slightly better. I noticed that if I applied thicker layers of product to my lids, the shadow would crease after 6 hrs of wear so I...
MAC eyeshadow in sketch

1 review

I am absolutely OBSESSED with this eyeshadow. I have had it for years and have recently rediscovered this. I legitimately wear this eyeshadow in several places. It blends like a dream and looks so so beautiful all blended out!
Pixi mesmerizing mineral palette Copper peach

1 review

Very nice eyeshadow palette. Great colour combination. Goes on smoothly and blends nice. Stays on all day. I did find I had to layer some a bit more to make the pigment show but that it all right by me because I have more control on my look achievement.
Pixi mesmerizing mineral palette opal glow

1 review

Great colour combination palette. The colour are more light shimmery perfect a glowing summery look. Great quality and the price is $16. You don't need a lot so it should last a long time!
L'oreal Paris infallible 24hr eyeshadow

1 review

I have these in liquid diamonds and endless sea. I am in love with these eyeshadows. They are pigmented, easy to blend, great for buildable coverage and their is little fallout. A home run was hit in my opinion with these. As soon as I am able I swear I'm going to go buy...
Designer Skin Angel Daily Moisturizer

1 review

I love this moisturizer. I always use it fresh out of the shower it is wonderful and the Kiwi smell is wonderful! It doesn't leave your skin greasy like most moisturizers. LOVE IT, totally worth the money.
Kiko Milano Water Eyeshadow

5 reviews

KIKO Milano's Water Eyeshadows can be used slightly wet for a stronger look or dry for a wash of brushed chrome shimmer. It's a buttery soft powder that comes in the shape of a mono eyeshadow.
Quo The New Blue Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

This Quo palette is the cutest thing I've ever seen!! It's tiny, it was on sale for only $2 and it opens & closes with a magnetic click! Très cute, contains 3 colours
Avon true color eyeshadow quad mocha latte

1 review

This is a multi (matte and glittery) eyeshadow quad. I think the colors are beautiful and sometimes I even use the darkest brown color to fill in my eyebrows.
STILA eyeshadow in Rose Quartz

1 review

This is one of my favourite shimmer eye shadows to work with, i picked this up from winners for $7, i like that it has pinkish purple tones to it, it really brings out my eyes whenever i use it when i go out
Hard candy look pro sassy eyes eyeshadow palette

2 reviews

Love how this pallet comes in a tin case with a removable lid. This eyeshadow looks perfect and stays on forever if you use it with the primer. You can buy the primer in a full size tube as well for cheap if you ever wanna use again!
Shiseido Eye Color Bar

1 review

The eyeshadows stay on the eyelids for a relatively long time without fading away or getting displaced. The palette is very versatile, with nude shades for everyday wear or more intense and vibrant colours perfect for parties. This product is high end, but every single penny is...
Batter Up Long Wearing Eyeshadow Stick by The Balm Cosmetics

1 review

These cream shadow sticks are very long lasting, work great as a base for powder shadow, look great worn on their own and come in a range (8) of beautiful very wearable shades. They cost a reasonable $17 each. I definitely recommend and I will be purchasing more!
Almay intense i-color shimmer-i for Greens

1 review

I purchased this on a whim because I was really drawn to the deep emerald crease colour that I find goes well with my dark brown hair. I was so pleasantly surprised by the quality and pigmentation of these shadows! The green especially as I've hardly made a dent in because it is...
Tarte Cosmetics Color Vibes Amazonian Clay Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

For $60 you get 20 full sized shadows in gorgeous mattes, shimmers and satins. Features a full sized mirror. Amazonian clay formula is richly pigmented, buttery soft and also benefits the skin. Love this palette!
anastasia self made palette

2 reviews

In my honest opinion, I don't know why Anastasia palettes need a review. They are all stunning, blend well and capture your heart. The formula is amazing. In terms of color, it's just a matter of taste. I highly recommend all her palettes and I'd gift them all to a loved one..
CoverGirl Eye Enhancers Brown Smolder Eyeshadow

1 review

If you have brown hair and brows or want a good, inexpensive contour eyeshadow, you need to add this to your makeup kit. It is so versatile. I've used it to achieve a smokey eye look, to fill my eyebrows and I've also applied it as a liner to my lids. The consistency is smooth...