This is by far the best waterproof I have ever used. I've tried different brands over the years but they never performed like this! I have skimpy short lashes and this formula and the stiff brush lengthens and separates beautifully without clumping

There's a reason this mascara frequently comes out on top in blind testing in magazine articles. This is a classic. It's the perfect consistency for a mascara, not too runny and not too thick. The brush might be simple with no fancy shapes or weird vibrations, but there's a reason for that; it works, simply. It doesn't need bells and whistles because it's the perfect basic mascara for your base makeup kit. The price is amazing for this staple beauty product.

Get this in waterproof and use an old business card or credit card to prevent smudges on the eyelids during application. Comb through after and you're ready to go. You can do double for really bold lashes, but one is enough for an everyday look.

This is a great waterproof mascara! It is very effective. Stays on all day, weather you're swimming or crying!

It is does not run down face when in the water. However it leaves slight smudges underneath eyes.

This is my go to mascara! First, for a woman who wears contacts- you need to find something that specifically says, "OK for contact lens wearers" on it. If not, don't even touch it!! Second, this stuff lasts! I have a product that is 4 times the price of this and it crumbles off mid day. Last, seeing as mascara needs to be thrown out every 2-3 months for sanitary purposes, this is a great quality and amazing priced product! Buy it!

This stuff has stood the test of time! Probably the only mascara that does not clump on my puny lashes. I like the small brush, and the fact that it is, an actual brush, not one of those plastic brushes. Cheap as dirt,reliable. I like using blackest black and brown, and I like the clear when I want my lashes to look neat, but not done up.

This mascara is great. I use the waterproof on the days I know I will need it. It doesn't run nor smudge and make you look like you have a black eye.

This has been my go to drugstore mascara for years! It lasts all day without clumps or flakes and makes my eyelashes look fabulous but still natural. Plus, this is one of the most cost effective mascaras out there. Love it!

Nothing special...doesn't really make your lashes look any better ... It's not bad either though it's ok I guess

Nothing special about this mascara.. it's good if you're just looking for a basic look, but it won't take your lashes above what they currently are.