Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Mascara

What really turns me off about this mascara (and the latest ones from maybelline) is the strong smell. Very strong. It makes my eyes water and I don`t even have sensitive eyes. I don`t get why would they add fragrance (this much fragrance) to a mascara, a product designed for the most sensitive areas, the eyes. Aside from that, It was a pretty blah Mascara. I was expecting a more elaborate brush, that could give me the length and sculpt my lashes... but the average wand didn`t do any of that.
In my opinion this mascara is a miss. Below average.

I can't say how much I am satisfied with this mascara! What I look for the most when I buy a mascara is that it has to be lengthening. I already have long and noticeable lashes without mascara and I just love to add a lot of mascara to give my lashes a dramatic, well-defined look. I am very pleased with this one and I have used it everyday since I first bought it 2 months ago. It applies easily and smoothly, doesn't clump at all and separates each hair while lengthening them. Don't buy this mascara if you need volume because it is not what it claims to add. I find that it lengthens A LOT my already long lashes, which is amazing. I feel like it sculpts them and put each hair in its right place. I find it simply fantastic and I love the packaging too. I find it much better than other drugstore mascaras I have used and way better than high end mascaras such as Lancôme.

Please people, use an eyelash curler or don't complain! A curler is a must, whatever mascara you're gonna use it makes a huge difference.

If you are looking for light, natural everyday lashes then this is your mascara. Its very good at lengthening and it does not clump or flake.
The wand is thin and easy to use. This mascara doesnt cost alot and can be found at most drug stores and dept stores. I got mine at Target. I use the soft black shade and the nice thing about it is it washes off easily and comes in a few different shades of black and brown.

The packaging alone of this mascara makes you want to buy it but it actually does what it claims. Maybelline claims you will have "the hottest length lashes will ever wear" and I agree. You don't even have to curl your lashes prior to application to receive these results. The only thing I dislike about this product is the scent, I almost stopped using it after one application as a result but I'm glad I didn't as it really is an award worthy mascara. Give it a try and see for yourself!

Its most deff a product I would buy again . The price was affordable and the product worked perfect and lasted long on me.

So, I stooped to the brilliant marketing on this one. Love the packaging- it's a sexy stilleto heel. And I was drawn in by the claim to its "black patent high gloss shine". I have thin, but long lashes and when a decent mascara is used, I'm able to achieve a good look. I thought the "shine" factor would add just that little bit more to really make them stand out. (Why didn't someone think of that sooner?) I used it for a week before I gave it to my daughter. She didn't like it either. I didn't really like the way the brush applied; it seemed kind of - uneven? Some lashes would be gooped up and others were missed. I didn't see any noticable shine. There was definitely a raccoon look to my eyes by the end of the day. I tried to like it, I really did, but in the end, clever marketing got me and I went back to my old favorite, Loreal Double Extend lash tips.

I used this for about a week and ended up switching back to my old mascara. It works alright but it doesn't really do much for me. I wouldn't recommend it. Plus it a little to watery for me.

so i have medium sized lashes. well i saw a commercial for the new stilleto mascara and it was amazing! my eye lashes look more full and wide and long! really brings out my brown eyes! I recommend it to anyone!

This was probably the best mascara ever. It definitely works

My mother raised me a Maybelline girl so there has always been a place in my heart for their brand. Maybelline Great Lash Mascara and I are old friends so it was a big step for me to pay $11.99 for a tube of Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Mascara. But I did it anyway. Because Maybelline has done right by me.

Honestly, the best advice I can give to anyone in the market for mascara experimentation is not to 'judge the book by the cover.' Sure, this mascara might be shaped like a stiletto, but that's where the comparison ends.

I don't mean to tell you that this is a bad product though. In theory, it isn't. The product works fine and would be perfect if every woman out there wanted ONE eye to look fantastic for the night. Instead of both. Or if everyone were pirates. It just seems that by the time you get that one eye perfectly coated, you've run out. And who's going to buy 2 tubes of mascara just to have intense eyes for the night? You might as well buy falsies.

It goes on relatively smooth but it comes off even smoother - which I can't say is really a characteristic I look for in mascaras. Touch your eye the wrong way or break any sort of sweat and it'll be all over your hands or your face. But don't worry, it will only be one eye, because there wasn't enough of it in the tube to do both.

Overall, it's on it's way to becoming a high-quality Maybelline product, but it's not quite there yet. I'll stick to my $6.99 Maybelline Great Lash Mascara. It's recession-proof and I only need to buy one tube at a time (except when they come in the 2 packs at Wal-Mart)!