This is great if you don't have really bad dark circles. So moisturizing but not enough coverage on its own for me.

I really like this concealer ! It works for my dark circle and my redness

I used this throughout my whole summer and will repurchase it again the concealer is very mousturizing and doesn't look caked on, Even on my acne prone days this thing worked like a charm, definately will be one of the staples in my make up collection

best for medium coverage, the added moisturizer is nice

I have this and the Benefit Erase Paste and while they both do similar things, they offer very different results. I'm hesitant to give this a higher grade, only because it isn't ONLY an under eye concealer, this is a very valuable under-eye-moisturizer as well. I tend to use Fake Up on days where I don't want to have lots of makeup on my face, on days where I want a more natural or 'fresher' look. It's not for the days when you have huge bags under your eyes. Would be a better score if it was a little less expensive.

I think this product is very good, I really liked how it worked under my eyes =).

When I first tried this concealer, I was unconvinced. It's a very creamy, moisturizing formula and I was used to thicker, heavier ones. I didn't think it would give any coverage or have any staying power. I have to admit, after using up the entire stick, I was wrong. This is a great concealer for those with drier skin. It's very hydrating and because it is so creamy, it glides on smoothly. It's great for those with dry patches. That being said, for those with especially oily skin, I don't know if this would be my first choice, because it is a lot wetter (if that makes sense) it tends to slip a bit. You'll definitely need to set it with a powder. I find underneath my eye area, it tends to settle into lines as well. It did give great coverage though, without looking cakey which is key for me. The packaging is cute and practical. The only down side is the price. At $30, I am not sure if I will repurchase it. It's not that I don't think it is worth it but I do think that there are similar options for a bit less.

I'm really impressed with this concealer & I find myself reaching for it all the time. While the shade range is rather sparse (three shades -- light, medium, deep), the product itself is great. It's super creamy and hydrating and has plenty of coverage, great for the eye area (although I don't really suggest it for spots). The packing is cute and really convenient -- a lipstick/twist up style tube. It's much different from Benefit's other concealers (which are still nice, too). It's higher end and a little on the pricey side, but I really suggest giving it a try!