Hi their I bought this new black cream eyeliner from Claire's and I am very impressed! It comes in a nice/neat little tub with a good quality angled brush.It was surprisingly easy to use ( getting a straight line).It soft to apply and it stays on all day/evening until you take it off,It looked just as good @ 9 pm as it did @9am! It's regularly 6-7$ but I got it on sale for.50$.Even at 7$ trust me it's awesome. I've used lots of different brands and now this is on my favorites list too.I have been wearing eyeliners for years and was pleasantly surprised.