Not good

I had high hopes that this product would be good and could be a dupe to substitute my other gel liners. Unfortunately it’s not good. The formula is crumbly and does not apply smoothly. Don’t waste any money on this.

Sad

The first time I used this liner I loved it. It went on smooth and super black. Lasted all day..was great! Went to use it a week later and it was starting to dry out already and I just couldn't get it to work proper... it was flaky on my eye after an hour.. wouldnt buy again

There's Better Products Out There

In terms of affordable cream eyeliner, for the price it is a decent product. The brush that i comes with is very cheap and I found that when trying to apply more eyeliner to darken the line, the brush ended up actually removing the eyeliner I had previous applied. This can easily be solved by purchasing an alternative brush though. Another downside to the product is that it is not the most pigmented. When applied it, it appeared to be almost grey and you have to keep going over it to get a nice clean black line. I find that the negative attributes outweigh the benefits and I'd rather spend double the price and get a better product.