This eyeliner helped me perfect the cat eye and the 'winged' tip when I was first experimenting.
I like that one end is really fine, for precise precision, and the other end is round and easy to use to create a smokey top liner effect. You get a fair amount of both pencils, they are creamy and soft when applied and for the price you can't go wrong!

It gives a nice clean line the tip is thinner which i really like it glides easily giving a evry good wing although the tip does seem to dry out a bit but after i dip it in water than it works fine

This eyeliner comes off within an hour. If you touch it, it will come off like in 1 second. I used this for a couple of months and nothing happened to me. However, my sister would get a swallon eye/pimple on her eyelid, whenever she put it on. So after that I havent used it. It is cheap, and has a great tip to apply eyeliner. I wouldnt pay more than $3 for this.