Sadly Disappointed

After a long wait to try this product (due to the price), I found this product to be ineffective. I found it to be very dry compared to most liquid liners and because of the dryness, it ends up taking liner off when I go over to darken with a second coat. I have used a cheap drugstore brand of eyeliner for my cat eyes for years and had heard so many great things about this eyeliner I decided to try it but was disappointed by the quality and the lack of product. I found that it dried up and only lasted about 4 wears before it seemed to have run dry. I will continue to use my cheap drugstore eye liner.

Not Worth It

I wanted to like this eyeliner and gave it a fair trial. Both tubes I purchased from Sephora were dried out and useless. With a lot of work I managed to get some product to come out, but when I attempted to apply my liner it wouldn't stay, and trying to go over a line simply wiped up what I had already applied. I'll stick with my Stila, thank you very much.

Not waterproof

This concealer is not waterproof and smudgeproof as it claims. My eyelids are not that oily. Not recommended for special events when crying is going to happen. Sorry Kat Von D

disappointing

Not very pigmented. Difficult getting a straight line. I would make a small line and the tip would dry out, I have to re-shake it after every small stroke.

There are better liquid eyeliners out there...

I got two sample sizes of this eyeliner in brown and black and was very disappointed. The sponge-like applicator was nice to work with but they dried out so fast. At first I thought that I just got a bad one but it was both of them. The brown wasn't very strong or opaque in colour. I had to go over the lines a few times for it to show nicely. But if it dried too quickly, going over it again would wipe off the lines. For both the black and the brown I found that if I accidentally touched the corners of my eyes, the liner would rub off. I'd end up with missing sections of liner. It was awful. I really wanted it to work :(

You win some, you lose some.

I ordered this liner because of all the great reviews but don't waste your money. I used it once.
Then the tip started to fray and it has completely dried out at the tip.
So, I'm back using my Loreal liquid liner felt pen.

Pas impressionner

Je n'aime pas vraiment donner de commentaire négatifs sur un produit. Mais je me dois d'etre honnete. J'avais lu beaucoup de point positif a acheter ce liner. Malheureusement, le trait sur mon oeil est tres pale et je dois appliquer plusieurs couches afin d'optenir un noir plus profond. Je suis tres deçue car je sais que Kat Von D font généralement de bons produits. Toutefois, je ne racheterai pas celui-ci.

I also heard rave reviews over this liner, and was very excited to try it out. Unfortunately the brush wasn't the greatest (in my opinion), and I found it was not very pigmented. This made drawing a thin line very difficult, as when I went over the colour again to get it a bit darker, it continued staying the same. Overall it was very expensive for a mediocre product, and there are definitely better options out there for the same price range.

This eyeliner did not work for me! I found it difficult to apply, I would have to keep adding layers for the black to appear. I found after a few hours, it would be faded or smudged. Not impressed. I am still a big fan of the Stila Eyeliner.

I'm sure this liner works better in other colours, but I bought the felt-tipped eyeliner in "Neruda" (white) and it was almost translucent the pigmentation was the weakest I've ever seen, and certainly the weakestt I've ever paid $23 for! no amount of shaking, rolling, pumping, upside-down-storing would make it actually be white. I tried to apply it in layers to build up the colour, and as soon as it touched my eye makeup it started drawing this watery dingy grey. Absolutely not worth it. If you want a white liquid eyeliner, get the NYX one for $12.