I received this eyeliner as a Christmas gift, which was an amazing present from a friend who knows how much I appreciate quality products but don't always have the money to spend on it. Unfortunately, I wasn't as keen on this eyeliner for the price. I enjoyed using it, I found the colour was consistent but not the thickest formula, it's a bit watery which makes it easier to smudge BUT also easier to correct immediately. Once set it would last for quite awhile however. The flexible tip is nice but unless you're really doing fancy eyework, it's not necessary.

I enjoyed the product but it literally needs to be half the price for me to purchase it again. I'd rather go back to Annabelle.

The applicator is quite flexible which I think for a beginner is pretty hard to work with. However with practice, beautiful clean lines can be created! Fine and thick lines included. The tip is pretty fine which makes filling in a wing for winged eyeliner look, look perfect :)

The consistency is watery just like a lot of users have told me. Watery consistency makes it hard to work with, but it's also a good thing because mistakes can be wiped out with a q-tip immediately. The pigmentation is not super black because of the watery consistency, but can be build-able to a jet black if needed. You have to wait for this to dry before applying any eyeshadow, and it dries with a shiny sheen appearance (which I don't mind). Removal is also very easy!

Overall:

Price: 1/5 - $34 is too expensive!
Applicator: 4/5 - Can create clean lines :)
Formula: 3/5 - Too watery (good and bad).
Packaging: 3/5 - Nothing that special.
Lasting power: 4/5 - It lasts mostly all day, however I wore it on a sticky humid day for the whole day and it started to flake off :( I need to try with a primer next time!