Not worth $40+ tax

I purchased 5 of these Black, 04,06,07,08
These are really nice liners, they glide really smooth (though the brush doesn't take on a lot of colour) have to a apply a few coats, must shake product a few times to get better colour, dry pretty fast, the bendable wand is pretty cool & is useful, the packaging is very elegant. They have nice shades of the liners.The liner doesn't stay on all day it - comes off in dry pieces. Glad I only paid $5.00 each at a Estee L sale.

Not quite what I expected

I spent about 50 dollars on this eyeliner thinking that I have finally found an eyeliner that is similar to one that is not available in Canada. I was looking for an eyeliner that is waterproof and smudge proof and this was just that at the start. I only go for dip in liquid eyeliners and I never have a problem with applying it on but my main problem with eyeliners is always that they start to dry out from the bottle after a very short amount of time. This barely lasted 3 weeks and it was always difficult to apply eyeliner everyday because it would be so dry as if it was finished. Another problem is that the tip started to change shape and become fluffy and maybe that was just a problem with mine but my experience with it was not worth the overprice.