It went on with ease and lasts good. Its cheaper than most and I will buy again. I was able to sleep and wake up and it still was on. I like this product

This eyeliner is very good and very black
my only complaint and thing that holds me back from using this product more is the applicator/wand its too straight and long and hard to use

This eyeliner has a learning curve to it, the brush is not as sturdy as some of the other felt tip brushes on eyeliner, and so I found it hard to line a very thin line with this. The formula for this is matte, but it is flaky, and does not last very long. If you try to fix mistakes with a q-tip, the eyeliner flakes off. When wet, this runs, and is messy to clean up.

Great Product and easy to use however the price is a little more then i would like to pay for this product.

I have used classical eyeliners for a while now, but recently I decided to try a liquid one. I chose NYc since their quality is widely appreciated.
1. The eyeliner, the liquid itself is really good. It stays for a whole day. Not like a usual pencil which you have to reapply.
2. If you did not have a previous experience with a liquid eyeliner you will probably cry and freak out since it is extremely difficult to make it look good. You have to be an artists.
3.The price is higher than for the conventional product.
To sum up, I would not recommend the liquid eyeliner, but NYC still does a good job.

This is a definite must have in a make up collection works great.

This was the first Liquid Eyeliner I bought. I don't like pencil there hard to put on. It is very easy to put on you can get it everywhere. you have to put it back on about every 4 hour because its flakes out. But its a very good product.

Its a must have !!!

This eyeliner was one of my first makeup purchases, mostly because it was the cheapest liquid eyeliner I could find. Back then I was still experimenting with how to properly put on cosmetics and I fell in love with this product because the brush tip made the application so smooth and precise. To be fair, I hadn't tried much else other than cheap pencil liners, so I stuck with using this liquid eyeliner because it gave me a dramatic look without spending so much effort trying to get colour out of the pencils.

Over time, my skills improved and I even began getting compliments on the way I did my eyeliner. I started referring all my friends to this product, and it became a part of their daily routines as well (though they don't use nearly as much as I, because I have conservative friends who like subtle makeup). So yes, this eyeliner is extremely versatile.

I have been using this product for five years now, and I still do every day because it is so convenient and inexpensive. It may not be waterproof and it does flake if you leave it on for a long time without touchups, but it does a very good job for just a day of going out. I love this eyeliner and I will continue to purchase it, even though I can afford a much more expensive brand, because it does an impressive job for such a reasonable price.

I tried this a few times but just not used to using the liquid eyeliner, smudge a lot on me and feels very sticky.