I always fall for the Doctor

I did not see a single lash spout a single millimeter so yet again I have been lied to about size from a DR. First he tells me its 8 inches (lies) then he says I am over weight (the balls of him) and now he deceives me with his promises of longer lashes..... Like all men and liquid eyeliners I've met, they are ok, just not the right one.

I used this eyeliner hoping to improve the length of my short, sparse lashes. Even if it didn't improve the length, I was hoping the serum would at least prevent the lashes from falling out so much lashes would look fuller. Unfortunately with a couple months of use, it didn't really change anything in the appearance of my lashes. I know products work differently for different people, but it didn't work for me, and because of that I wouldn't recommend it.

Another bargain bin buy - I got a two-pack of this product at Burlington Coat Factory for $5 when normal retail price is something like $10 for just one. To be fair, I have not noticed any significant difference in the length of my eyelashes after using this product, but I didn't buy it for that reason anyway. I bought it because I wanted a new liquid eyeliner, and if it happened to lengthen my eyelashes in the process, then that was just a plus.

As an eyeliner, this product works like a felt tip marker and is similar to L.A. Girl's Mark My Eyes eyeliner, but not quite as bold. But, to be fair, this eyeliner is meant to just kind of look like eyeliner while enhancing the lashes, so I'll give it a pass. It feels a little tingly when applied to the eyelids and it does go on smooth, but as with most felt tip liners, you have to make sure the tip stays free of things like eyeshadow residue, lest it become clogged and unusable.

The liner does wear off a little quicker than I thought it would and can easily be covered with eyeshadow. So for anyone who purchases this with the intention of volumizing their eyelashes, I would suggest putting this on first, then eyeshadow over it, then another liner on top, tracing the faint line left by the felt tip liner. I wouldn't buy this product if it wasn't on sale either - I know Physician's Formula is higher end than Wet N' Wild, but I would never in my life spend $10 on any eyeliner, even if it did promise fuller lashes.

Mind you, this isn't a horrible product, but it's also not worth the cost. If you want to add volume to your eyelashes, I would recommend looking for a different lash-boosting serum and using volumizing mascara, of which there are many fantastic choices available. For an eyeliner, I would recommend the one I mentioned before if you want a good felt-tip liquid liner: L.A. Girl's Mark My Eyes.

Well now I'm kind of torn on RECOMMENDING this product, because it's SO expensive for what it's worth but I do love it. I actually bought it only because ChickAdvisor was giving out $9 coupons for Physician's Formula stuff, otherwise I probably would have never touched it. But I bought the Kohl's Kajal Liner Trio, so it comes in brown, black, and purple. First off, the brown pencil broke before I even got a chance to use it, so that was really upsetting. But I LOVE the purple shade, it's not too intense but really brings out my eyes. The black is average, like most black liners, but what can you do. I probably wouldn't buy the trio again but I do love the purple like I said.

This eyeliner does not work well. It is difficult to apply and smudges very easily. The bold tip does not help to apply the eyeliner and it does not go on smoothly. The one good thing is that it does is stay on afterwards although the ink does fade as time goes on, but if you cry or even rub your eyes, it's coming right off. I do not recommend this to anyone. It is not worth it.