I too bought this hoping it would do the trick but I must say it was a disaster very messy!!! It constantly stuck my eyelashes together or to my lid was soo sticky feeling, Do not buy this!!!!!!

Fairly Cheap, But Also low in quality.
the brush is sponge tip and very hard to work with, and the colors compared to to non waterproof collection are limited.
with use of a separate liner brush, it might be good.

I got this eyeliner because it's hard to find liquid eyeliner in waterproof, and I had high hopes even though it was cheap, but I was very dissapointed. Although the packaging was cute, the product didn't work at all. It left a sticky mess on my eyelids and smeared onto my skin everytime i opened my eyes, and it wasn't waterproof at all. It wasn't even black, it was more of a bad grey. I gave it three tries before I threw it out. Don't waste your money.