We would like to send you notifications on the latest Product Review Club offers.

Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
21-40 of 1577

The Body Shop Shimmer Cubes

11 reviews

THE BODY SHOP SHIMMER CUBES are awful! I had high hopes, but the powder does not stay in place (ends up on your face), it doesn't last and it creases badly. If you are a contact lens wearer, they will end up shimmery by the end of the night. Very disappointed!
QUO Mineral Matters Eye Duo

3 reviews

I love Quo make up! I recently tried this "Duo" eye shadow at a friend's house.. She's practicing to become a make up artist, so she happened to use this on me. I absolutely loved the outcome! The look was fabulous, and was subtle but bold.. a nice combination. There was a nice...
Lise Watier La Toscana Eye Shadow Quartet in Mer

2 reviews

I love the colors but very dissatisfied with the leak of pigmentation in the powders. You cannot get a decent amount into the skin to show. Their faded and translucent like. I don't recommend, though if your not into high pigmentation colors then this is great for you.
Stila Eyeshadow - Kitten

16 reviews

Kitten by Stila is in everyones makeup bag. It is such a pretty color and so versitile. It can be used as a all over lid color, a highlight color, or a blender. It wears well and is overall amazing. A definte staple in my bag.
NYX Professional Makeup Hot Singles Eyeshadow

74 reviews

NYX mono eye shadows are similar to MAC's single eye shadows, cute, adorable pots of blendable powder shadow, some are shimmer, some matte, some a pearlescent or frost effect and all the colours are highly pigmented with high definition colour pay off, you get a good hit of...
Lise Watier Toscana Eye Shadow Quartet in Terre

2 reviews

Je n ai pas aimé ce Produit, bien que les couleurs Soient belles, il est difficile à appliquer Et ne Donne pas un beau fini au final. Je suis déçu de mon achat.
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers Eye Shadow

76 reviews

Underrated shadows that have been around forever. Soft and silky, with great staying power. Is both a user and beginner friendly formula. Buildable coverage. Tapestry Taupe is my go-to everyday shadow, for a single shadow look. It is a soft and cute cool taupe, very flattering...
Urban Decay Deluxe Shadow Box

10 reviews

I love all the fun, bold colours to play with!😍 Not the best for everyday, natural looks unless you’re into it! —Then heck yeaa it is! As a newbie amateur, I find them easy to blend and build up. There is a ton of fallout, which I don’t like because sometimes I decide...
L'Oreal Paris HIP High Intensity Pigments Eye Shadow Duo

116 reviews

I love majority of the colors from this line and I am impressed by the intensity of these 2 colors. I pair this with other colors for a simple day look. I love l'oreal eye shadows!!!
Mark Mini Mark-it Stick For Eyes - Cocoa Bean

2 reviews

I think this product looks so cute, so I was hoping it would work really well. The idea is great, a portable pencil that works as an eyeshadow! I have had portable pencils before, and some have worked great. These are such cute colours, so I wanted it to work. Having said that...
Milani Minerals Eye Shadow Compacts

2 reviews

These aren't pigmented and they crease very fast.
Clarins Colour Quartet for Eyes #50 - So Chic

1 review

I got this palette to review from the people at Clarins and I am smitten with it. I have been testing a lot of eye shadows but this one is the very best. The colours are rich and decadent. It goes on smoothly, doesn't budge, and a little goes a long way. And for once, the...
Everyday Minerals Eyeshadow

4 reviews

You can choose a free sample kit from everyday mineral and choose the colors you want and just pay shipping. I did this and pay like $3 por 4 shadows. They come in an small envelope so that’s why it save so much in shipping fees. The pigmentation of these shadows are...
Cargo Eyeshadow Palette in Bermuda

2 reviews

I love this palette from Cargo Cosmetics. All of the colours in it are very wearable for everyday. There are 4 colours and you can create variety of eye looks with them. I also liked that they lasted all day. The packaging is absolutely beautiful too. They different palettes...
CARGO Eyeshadow Palette in Toronto

2 reviews

Received this as a gift for Christmas and I love it! The colours are very nice and pigmented, not too much fallout :) haven’t done much research on the brand but I seen that they are cruelty free which is very important to me!
L.A. Colors 5 Color Metallic Eyeshadow

7 reviews

I would buy this product again. I love the company and how they keep up on the makeup trends. I will always be a avid L.A. Colors girl! The eye shadow will stay all on day and night, if you are like me a forget to wash makeup off after a long day.
Maybelline Expertwear Eye Shadow

15 reviews

Super choix de couleurs surtout si on veux matcher une couleur de vêtement avec ces yeux. Bonne qualité car il reste en place et ne brise pas. Je l'ai échappé une ou deux fois et il est encore intact.
Mary Kay Mineral Eye Shadow

13 reviews

This is the first eye shadow that I have ever found that doesn't settle in the creases of your eyelids. I love the color selection too, it adds to the overall value of the line.
Almay Intense i-Color Play Up Powder Shadow

13 reviews

I purchased the palette for brown eyes 2 years ago and used it often. Once it was used up i went to buy a new palette but found out they changed the packaging. It was in a rectangular pack but now it was in a circle. After 2 weeks, 2 colurs had crumbled and fallen out. would not...
GOSH Cosmetics Quattro Eye Shadow

3 reviews

Gosh is now my go to make up. I love the quattro eyeshadow. The colours are beautiful and blend together beautifully. I can create a gorgeous smoke look that you would think was done professionally. The colour lasts all day and stays vivid. Try it you won't regret it.