I really wanted to like this product. Maybe I just got an old product but mine was super hard and chalky. It also kept breaking when I applied a tiny amount of pressure.

I did not like this one at all. I wear it on both my top and bottom lids and it does not stay on. It runs down my face and I look terrible within an hour of putting it on. It is very oily. I would not buy again.

Dear god. Worst eye liner i have ever bought. And i buy quite a few for dance. It's way too soft of a consistency for eye liner. Ever without smudging, it still looks awful. After a maximum of an hour it's smudged halfway down your eye. Doesn't stay put whatsoever and it creates dark rings of black.

REVIEW: At first, I was so excited to get this product. I heard a lot of great things and I loved the packaging. (It's neon green so of course it's a conversation starter) I was also loved this product when I first started using it. I loved how bold and black it was (I'm wearing it in my icon picture, and just look how defined that line is), but unfortunately this product started to disappoint me. It smudges like crazy, and it doesn't last long. When you reapply it, it just smudges eve more, causing even more of a mess, causing you to look like a raccoon. This is definitely NOT a good product, and I would not recommend it to anyone. Unfortunately, I would not recommend any Maybelline eyeliner to anyone. (At least, according to my experience).