I have this in the sparkly black shade. This is the absolute worst eyeliner I've used when it comes to smudging. As soon as I put it on, it smudges. If that's the look I'm going for, it's good, but there are a lot of times when I just want to line my upper lash line and have it stay put. In that respect, it's almost laughably bad.

I see a bunch of people raving about this on Youtube. People use this in their waterline and it apparently stays all day. All I can say is, HOW? Maybe I just got a dud, but this stuff is way too soft. I like an eyeliner that goes on smoothly, but it just doesn't adhere to my skin and moves around immediately. There's no way it's waterproof, and I don't even use it on the waterline.

I just bought this and am soooo disappointed. I was hoping waterproof would mean it would stay where I put it but alas it doesn't. I used it on my top lash line and almost immedately the line ended up on the crease of my eyelid - all the way across my eye. I tried putting a little eye shadow on it to make it stay but that didn't work either. It is indeed waterproof though as I couldn't get it off my crease!