I use #651 Black Black/Noir Noir. This pencil is very good and doesn't fade or fall off. It is has a rich color, and a creamy texture that glides on smoothly without any tugging or pulling. It is long lasting and there is hardly any smearing.
This pencil is far too cheaply made and it scratches. It does not sharpen properly and it is very rough on the eye. In fact, after the first few tries, I stopped using it around my eyes and now just dab a spot on my eyebrows on rare occasions. It does a fair job when using it to fill eyebrow spots.
I bought this liner on the same day in two colors (601A - Baby's Got Black & 603A Simma Brown) more than a year ago and both pencils are still pretty tall. They now stay in my makeup case to remind me to not buy again.
I do no recommend this product for eyes. I do (slightly) recommend it to be used sparingly on brows, if you have nothing else and only when needed.
This pencil does the trick but there are definitely better ones out there. I bought mine from walmart and there wasnt a huge variety of colors, just the basic browns and blacks but this product is very well priced.
This is a really nice product,I like using it,its very precise and does what I want it to
Super affordable and works really well! It goes on really easily and you don;t have to reapply it. I have blue eyes so the brown eyeliner makes my blue eyes really stand out and makes them look prettier!
Great price and great for everyday!! I use this for my brows with a gel on top and it stays in place keeping my brows groomed and filled in!!
I have trouble finding an eyeliner that isn't dry and is not as dramatic as a liquid liner. This product works well but I would love one that's even better at doing the job without having to go over and over the lid for adequate coverage. This is the best of many I have tried.
I liked the moss green Wet n Wild ColorIcon eye liner with taupe and pewter shadows. Because it's neither golden nor silvery, more people can use the same green liner. It's extremely neutral for a color pencil. If you're my color or darker, try color liners on the lower lash line and always apply black to the upper lash line.
It smudges well, sharpens well and lasts all day. Most pencils of that price just split and crumble in a sharpener, but not this one.
These eyeliners are really great and very inexpensive. They're very smooth and creamy and they have great lasting power. They're obviously not the highest quality, but they work exceptionally well considering the price (less than $1 USD in your local drugstore). The shades are all very pretty, but I find that the neutral shades are the best quality (white, brown, black). I really like the brown one for my eyebrows. It's too harsh when applied directly from the brush to the brow, but I use an angled liner-type brush and it works great! The texture is a little waxy, so it stays in place and doesn't budge. Good product and great buy.
These reviews are the subjective opinions of ChickAdvisor members and not of ChickAdvisor Inc.