I bought the mini to try it for $12 and I fell in love. Maybe its helpful that I bought the mini because I can really get in close and have better control with the brush and have really separated lashes with no clumps. And if your favorite mascara isn't working the same like it use to its probably just to old and time to replace it. For sure worth the try.

I personally really like this mascara although it is not water proof and I do have to check my eyes every 4 or 5 hours or so to make sure it hasn't smudged. I do find that it lengthens, curls, volumizes, lifts & separates though and leaves my eyelashes looking great, unless it smudges. It was my first "high-end" mascara and I do find that it works better for me than the drug store brands. I love that it doesn't clump and it can be built on. however, for the price its def only a mascara that I would use occasionally as I'm too cheap to spend the $28 on a regular basis. I loved that it really did add volume to my lashes and have actually had people compliment my lashes while wearing it.

I absolutely love this mascara! I was at the Benefit counter trying on something else, and the sales person showed me this new mascara, putting it on one eye so I could compare - wow. You could really see the difference vs my normal drugstore brand mascara.

I like this because I feel like it makes my eyes look great and 'finished' every time I'm wearing it, even when I don't have any other makeup on. It lengthens my lashes, finds all the little side lashes that you don't usually reach, and I can layer it as thick as I like without it clumping. I normally have major clumping issues with every mascara I use and this is the first one that, three months on, is still working just as good as the day I got it.

Overall great defining mascara, would definitely recommend. While the price is higher than you could get with some other brands, it's worth it for the great lasting quality.

Overall I rate this mascara as not bad. I do like the wand, it's the perfect size and makes the mascara easy to apply and to get those small corner lashes. It goes on pretty well, not clumpy and one coat will do in a hurry or for a less dramatic look.

A little pricey for the end result but if I saw it on sale I would pick up more of this.

If you are looking for a mascara that offers serious length in one swipe, look no further. I have very little time to put on makeup these days so I really appreciate a mascara that goes on perfectly with dramatic results in just one coat. I'd say this one is better for length than volume, but it really makes your lashes stand out. The price point is a bit on the higher side but it's a nice quality product that gets great results. I got mine free from the brand.

I was initially attracted to this mascara for the wand, the thicker the better, and then when I read the claims I was sold. Benefit claims that this mascara "lengthens, curls, volumizes, lifts & separates. Our jet black, long-wearing formula won’t smudge or dry out. A specially designed brush reveals lashes you never knew you had!". I tested this product the only way a true makeup geek would by taking photos before and after. This mascara clearly lengthened my eyelashes and curled them however I didn't notice a big change in the volume of my lashes, which was slightly disappointing. Overall I think that this mascara is great, especially when you layer it with another mascara ( I like Makeup Forever Smoky Lash). I will most likely purchase this product again because compared to drugstore brand I think it does wonders.

Worth every penny makes your lashes look long and full without clumps!.. Really great product a must have for every girl!

This is the best mascara that I have tried! Having naturally long lashes, I am looking for a mascara that will curl and really add some drama. This mascara did just that! It actually looks like I have false lashes on when I am wearing this! Love it! I would repurchase for sure.

I was sceptical when this came out. I heard a lot about this, so after a month or so I went out and bought it. Best decision mascara-wise ever. It makes your lashes look great, evenly spaced long, thick, FALSE! So glad I bought it. The price is a bit steep but the tube will last you a while. Great buy!

This is the best mascara I have ever used (and man have I used a ton)! It gave my eyelashes amazing length and volume. It lasted all day without smudging which is a major plus! I would recommend this mascara to everyone!!