It's ok

I was looking for a new liqud liner & got this from a ipsy bag - perfect. The liner itself glides nicely, smooth,but it doesn't stay on all day.(it doesn't say waterproof) The shape of a pen is good.
I do like that its - Parabens - Sulfates - Phthalates + This product is vegan, gluten-free, and cruelty-free

So I am alittle disappointed for the price (that I saw on sephora) I probably wouldn't purchase it. Though it may be good for you.