I have Garnier's Anti Puff eye roller and really loved it. I naturally tried their anti-dark circle eye roller and must say I love it just as much. It goes on great under my eyes and does not leave a big watery residue but instead a light, cool wet feeling that dries fairly quickly. I find that when I use this I really notice a difference in the appearance of my dark circles. Every girl needs this in her purse/makeup bag just as a pick me up and freshen up those tired eyes!

OMG! I just bought this product for the first time a few weeks ago and I love it! The product is a little on the high side, but find a $3 off coupon online and wait for them to go on sale at SDM for 30% off bringing it to only about $12-13, AMAZING!
The coverage is amazing! Simple and easy to use! After smudging with finger and blending in to eyelid, no excess product builds up in crease. Simply awesome product! I have darker eyelids than the rest of my skin, so i always need a concealer to even-out my skin tone. This absolutely does the trick and hides my dark skin tone and dark circles around my eye! I've switched my regular concealer out to this one for my quick and easy two minute make-up routine. Busy moms on the go that need a quick fix, this is it!

I haven't used the non-concealer version of this so I can't speak to the effectiveness of that product or compared to this one. But I love this version.

Most concealers are too heavy for my under eye, and they end up creasing. I don't have particularly pronounced dark circles, but when I don't get enough rest my under eyes get a bit blue looking.
I have not used it long enough to see lasting effects on my under eyes, but when I use it I do notice immediate effects.
It covers up slight discolouration without looking cakey. It just gives a nice healthy, well-rested look to the area without looking unnatural.
I also appreciate that the product comes in a light shade, I am kind of pale and I can't always find a shade to match my skin.
It blends in very well and it's not TOO pigmented, which I think makes the colour match a bit more forgiving.
I like the amount of product you're getting too.

All in all, I really was not expecting to love this product! It was much better than i expected. I am a bit concerned about the ingredients, I heard it contains alcohol which could dry out your skin with long term use thus making dark circles even worse. So I only use it occasionally, when I look extra-tired.
Oh, and don't pay full price for this product! Regularily priced, it runs about 12-16 dollars (*AHEM* Shoppers Drug Mart) but I got it when SDM had a 40% off on Garnier Skincare, and price matched it at Walmart, so it was about 9 dollars. Would I pay 16$ for it? Probably not. But 9$ is more reasonable.

I bought this because I'm always noticing dark circles under my eyes. I didn't know if it would work wonders like I had heard, but at the price I bought it for who could go wrong. The next morning when I woke up to go to work I applied it, waited for 3 minutes for it to dry and my bags were gone. This product has been nothing but amazing and I will never go another morning without.