Meh

I had high expectations for this product but found it very underwhelming. The pigment was a bit disappointing and it smudged right away. For the price I really expected more. Not for me.

It's Okay

In my opinion, the Ink liner is often overshadowed by its more popular sibling, the Tattoo liner. I would have to say the Tattoo liner is better than the Ink liner due to its longevity and color pigmentation. I am also a fan of the brush of the Tattoo liner compared to the Ink!

Starts out great!

I am a liquid liner junky- specifically in the pen format. Whenever I see one I add to my collection. This liner was one of the first non drugstore i tried when I was old enough to shop at Sephora! It starts out really amazing and helps to achieve the perfect winged liner. But I find the flow becomes inconsistent very quickly - about 2 weeks of use (not everyday). When I am paying that much for a liner I’d like a little longevity. I’ve tried wiping the brush tip as others have suggested but no luck. I also thought I might have had a bad tube, so I did repurchase. Unfortunately, I had the same result.

I continue my hunt for the perfect liquid liner pen!

Doesn't work for me :(

I had heard so many good things about this eyeliner, so I was very disappointed when I didn't fall in love with it. I may just have a preference to liquid based eyeliners, but I found that it just didn't glide as smoothly on my eyes as I would have liked. I found that my much cheaper liquid liner from NYX did more for my winged liner than this one did .

It's alright

It has lasted doesn't dry up much. Started to break up a bit could be more liquidy maybe. My Sephora brand eyeliner works well too. Maybe not as precise but idk.

Good for top lash line NOT for the bottom.

I like the staying power of this liquid line and the applicator is great. But it doesnt apply to the bottom lashline very nicely. And i would prefer more of a matte finish this seems to have a bit of shine

Not my cup of tea

I used this product but on my skin it smudged, didn't stay in place, and was not even water resistant. The liner is very easy to use, but I want my liner to stay in place and never budge. I wouldn't repurchase.

A let down, personally

I used to use this product all the time as I don't go a day without my cat-eye. However, I realized I was buying into the hype. It's not a BAD product, but it just isn't great. I have used drugstore liner that gives me better results. The problem with this product is that it dries out very quickly. Your first few applications will be smooth, but then, for me at least, the tip began to dry out which lead to the product balling up when I went over lines, which is less than ideal. After a couple weeks of use, the colour had faded and the tip had to be dampened to get much out of it. I also noticed flaking throughout the day.

I bought this eyeliner at the recommendation of the woman working at Sephora and honestly it's meh. I find the application to be patchy since the tip tends to dry out pretty quickly if the liner isn't angled properly, then you end up wiping it off trying to fill in the gaps. For the price it's just not my favourite, there are much cheaper ones that do the same thing.

The eyeliner was great at first but quickly started drying out. It's really hard to build the profit because the new layer picks up the old layer so you end up with streaks. Doesn't last very long as a product and also tends to come off during the day. Save your money and buy something from the drugstore